How to Beat the Loop That's Wrecking Your Relationship
If, like most struggling couples, you keep having the exact same fight over and over, the solution lies in identifying the fixed roles you each take on during that fight
"My wife drives me out of my mind. She's constantly looking for reasons to fight with me. Nothing pleases her. Just this week we managed to fight about me not walking the dog, about me not wanting to go with her to her office's Purim party, and about me going out to eat with my older daughter (I have a daughter from a previous marriage, who in hindsight doesn't seem so terrible anymore) at a restaurant my wife had wanted to go to. I can't live with all these fights anymore, she's driving me crazy."
I got this email from a man in his second marriage, but I could have gotten it from plenty of other men. It seems like a lot of people feel their partner wakes up in the morning and immediately starts picking fights with them. No matter what they do, she always finds a reason to nag.
For every complaint like this, there's naturally an opposite version too. Like this one: "My husband is emotionally numb. Sometimes I suspect he has Asperger's. I do everything at home — cleaning, cooking, raising the kids. I'm even the one responsible for the relationship with his mother!!!! (who I think is to blame for everything, but never mind). I'm exhausted and on edge, and not only does he not help me with anything, but if I even dare to ask for something — and believe me, I think it over a thousand times before I dare ask — he immediately gives me this look like I'm some kind of slave driver, and it's incredibly insulting. The most infuriating part is that he doesn't even notice. He just goes to his computer, and I swear that most of the time, if you ask him, he doesn't even know what happened or what's wrong."
Do these people simply need to get divorced and find someone who'll make them happier? A less nagging wife, say? Or a husband more in touch with his feelings? From the perspective of Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) for couples, the answer is: absolutely not — and maybe even the opposite. From an EFT point of view, this couple, like about seventy percent of distressed couples, is stuck inside a cruel, painful loop of opposing defense styles that has robbed them of their ability to enjoy the relationship. The classic defense styles I described above are called "pursuing" and "withdrawing."

Broadly speaking, the pursuer is extremely sensitive to any sense that their partner is pulling away, and the moment they sense something that feels like distance, they start defending themselves by trying to pull their partner closer. The withdrawing partner, meanwhile, is extremely sensitive to criticism, and interprets the pursuer's attempts to get closer as — you guessed it — criticism. In response, they start to withdraw, meaning pull away. And we already know what distance does to the other partner: in response, they usually only intensify their attempts to get closer to the withdrawer, in their own doomed way. In other words, the basic trap is this: the very thing that makes one partner (the pursuer) feel protected causes the other partner pain, while the thing that makes the other partner (the withdrawer) feel protected causes the first one pain.
So if you recognize yourselves in this and want to understand what to do now, the first step toward escaping this miserable loop is to identify your own defense styles. In many cases, for various sociological reasons, women tend to develop the pursuing style and men tend to develop the withdrawing style — though of course reality is more complicated than that.
1. During a fight I tend to... A — criticize, attack, blame. B — defend myself, analyze, offer rational explanations for things, shut down and turn cold.
2. During a fight I feel... A — vulnerable, worried, on edge, disappointed, rejected, angry, emotionally flooded, wanting to cling to my partner, invisible, abandoned, desperate. B — rejected, unworthy, frozen, criticized, humiliated, like someone's trying to control me or belittle me, like I'm always failing, or like I don't feel anything at all.
3. During a fight, what I want most is... A — for my partner to finally start talking to me, to agree to talk about our relationship, to finally start dealing with the problems. B — for my partner to finally drop it, to get off my back, that I just don't want to talk about it anymore.
If you picked "A" more often, you don't need me to tell you who you are. You've already got at least one relationship book on your shelf, and after reading this post, there's a good chance you'll email it to your partner. But if you picked "B" more often, you might be interested to know you're not alone — your defense style is familiar and understandable, and contrary to what your partner thinks, you are not the problem in this relationship.
She isn't the problem in the relationship either. And that's actually the point. This screwed-up loop you're both stuck in is the problem in the relationship. This loop is a treadmill of behaviors, thoughts and feelings that cause you suffering, and that you keep running on like mice in a cage. You react to your partner, then they react to you, and it's all terrible and predictable. But there's also an advantage to understanding that it's not a brand-new fight every single time. Because now that you have some initial sense of your own defense style, you can move on to the next step and try to identify the buttons that set off each other's defense systems. So try observing your fight patterns from the outside and answering the following questions:
1. When my partner and I fight, I usually respond by......
2. When I do that, my partner usually responds by......
3. When my partner responds that way, I usually feel.....
4. When I feel that way, I start thinking that I am....... and thinking that they are........
5. At that point, what I actually, deeply long for — what would make me feel good — is.......
6. But instead, when I get pulled into our loop, the way I respond to my partner is by.....
7. And when I look at it from the outside, I can guess that my response makes my partner feel......
That's it. That's lesson one. It's not enough, of course. The loop is like a chute in a game of Chutes and Ladders — the moment you land on the wrong square, you can find yourself sliding rapidly all the way down. But recognizing that there is a loop, and that the loop — not your partner — is the problem, is the first step toward getting the enjoyment back in your relationship.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




