How Can Couples Break Free of the Fighting Loop?
The brain prefers bad news to good, which is why it is hard for people to be impressed by their successes. But if you want to improve your relationship, it is worth learning to do exactly that
Yoni and Ruti walk into my clinic and sit down on the couch. They sit more lightly than usual. This is not their usual collapse into the cushions. I know right away that they had a good week. I even venture a guess that they may have had sex, which doesn't happen often.
I smile at them and they smile back, but neither of them speaks yet.
"Are we going to play 21 Questions?" I ask.
"No... it's nothing..." Yoni says. "We had a good week...". He throws a hesitant glance at Ruti. "I think...".
"Yes," Ruti confirms, "although we did have that fight when your mother came over on Saturday..." she reminds him.
Yoni looks at me sheepishly, as if caught telling a white lie.
Ruti doesn't hesitate. She is already starting to reconstruct the details of that visit from her mother-in-law, which didn't go well.
"Wait," I stop her, "before we move on, I really want to know what made this week turn into a good week."
They fall silent.
"Nothing special," Ruti says.
"Right," Yoni agrees. "We had some argument at the beginning of the week, but somehow it didn't spiral into the usual loop. Somehow we got out of it... I don't know...".
"Right," Ruti agrees, "but about your mother...," she says, and the mood darkens.

This scene plays out in my clinic again and again. Couples skip over their successes and rush to report their failures. Sometimes it seems they see me as a probation officer or a school nurse, parting their hair with pencils to check for lice. Time after time I stop them and ask that we go back to the moments of success, even if those moments are small and fleeting. In fact, I suggest we linger on them, precisely because they are liable to evaporate without leaving a trace.
The standing campaign I wage "against" my couples' stance is called "learning from successes." My attempt to understand, together with the partners, what enabled them to succeed in a situation where they often fail almost always meets with a certain bewilderment. Sometimes suspicion flickers across their faces, as if I had suddenly revealed a New Age streak that I had managed to hide well until that moment.
This skeptical reaction is natural and predictable. Our brains have a preference for negativity. We come out of the factory more sensitive to bad news than to good news. One small example is a study by Dr. John Cacioppo, who measured the electrical activity in the cerebral cortex while participants looked at pictures of things like a Ferrari and a pizza, which evoke positive feelings (they are Americans, after all), and compared it with the brain activity that occurs when participants look at pictures of mutilated faces and a dead cat. He also compared all of this with the electrical waves active in the brain while participants viewed pictures of emotionally neutral objects, such as a plate or a hair dryer. Cacioppo's study showed, as expected, that our brain responds more strongly to negative stimuli.
It makes sense. The technology we carry between our ears evolved at a time when it was critical to remember which plant was poisonous and less important to know which plant was tasty, and to this day our survival depends on our ability to steer clear of danger. Like a restaurant owner who gives celebrities preferential treatment, our brain gives the best table to negative events, treats our successes like walk-in customers off the street, and parks them at the table by the restrooms.
But if our negativity bias is justified from a survival standpoint, why focus on successes anyway? I like to explain this through the availability heuristic, or accessibility heuristic, which you can read about with great pleasure in Professor Daniel Kahneman's book "Thinking, Fast and Slow." When our mind has to estimate the probability that a certain event will occur, it tries to imagine it. If the mind can imagine the event easily and vividly, it may judge the likelihood of the event to be high, regardless of the scenario's objective probability. This is one reason why our anxiety about stabbing attacks, for example, soars the more the media covers such events, and overshadows our anxiety about being hurt in a traffic accident, even though statistically our chance of being hurt in a traffic accident remains immeasurably higher than our chance of being stabbed, in any given period. That is because the possibility of being stabbed is more emotionally charged than a traffic accident, since it involves deliberate aggression, and it is easier for us to imagine a stranger lunging at us out of nowhere and stabbing us, because the media describes such scenarios in more vivid and detailed terms than it describes traffic accidents.
When we take into account the biological negativity bias of our brains and the availability heuristic of our thinking, we can see the psychological danger we face if we don't fight the negativity bias. If the brain records our failures in neon signs, while writing our successes in the sand with a stick, then when we find ourselves facing a difficulty we didn't handle well in the past, we may expect to fail this time too.
This phenomenon has fateful implications for relationships. Many couples are stuck in an endless loop of fights. For them there is almost no difference between today's fight, yesterday's fight, and the fight of six months ago. So if Ruti and Yoni don't marvel at their moments of success, and don't dare to really rejoice in them, however small they may be, there is a danger that the next time they argue, their brains will predict that the argument will lead to an explosion and to distance. Without dwelling on the positive, the information about the times when they actually managed to turn a fight into closeness will lose its relevance for each of their brains. That is why I insist on focusing on successes as well, rather than skimming over them. The approach of learning from successes is not unique, by the way, to emotionally focused couple therapy; parallels can be found in solution-focused therapy, in narrative therapy, and generally in the field of positive psychology, which focuses on strengths (a dreadful word, but an important idea) rather than on pathologies.
If Yoni and Ruti agree to dig into the small positive and close moments they experienced as a couple during the week, it will mean far more than they imagine. First, the very act of inquiry will show them that the good week did not simply happen on its own, arbitrarily, but was the product of good choices that both of them made. Second, delving into the small achievements will raise the chance that those achievements are recorded in their minds more dramatically. And so, the next time they fight, the memory of their success will be more accessible and tangible to them. When the information about success becomes accessible, their sense of efficacy will grow, and so will their chance of successfully extricating themselves from the next fight as well.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




