How an Affair Might Actually Improve a Marriage — and Whose Fault Is It, Anyway?
First post in a series inspired by couples therapist Esther Perel's new book on affairs and infidelity
Esther Perel has done it again. The couples therapist who shook up relationships worldwide about a decade ago with her provocative book Mating in Captivity has published a new book on an old subject: affairs outside of marriage. The book, The State of Affairs, is in a sense her answer to the question she posed in Mating in Captivity. The question was: can erotic tension be sustained in a long-term monogamous relationship? Perel's answer, in one word, is: yes. And in two words: no, it can't.
Her first book made clear that the concept of partners who are supposed to be both lovers and best friends was sold to the masses without ever being proven feasible. But compared to her significant contribution in defining the problem, the solution Perel pointed to back then was vague and abstract. If marriage is the germ that erodes a couple's sexual desire for each other, the antibiotic, according to Perel, rests on preserving an awareness of the "third" — some other potential person who could serve as an erotic object for our partner, or who sees our partner that way. The role of that third party — real or imagined — is to remind us not to take our partner for granted.
In other words, in Mating in Captivity, Perel seemed to be working within the framework inspired by the relational psychoanalyst Stephen Mitchell. Mitchell interpreted our boredom with our partner as an illusion we construct to reduce the anxiety that our dependence on that person stirs up in us. This illusion anesthetizes the pain embedded in knowing that we build our identity and entrust our heart to a person we can never truly fully know, simply because they are an other — someone who changes from day to day just as we do, with no guarantee that they'll remain devoted to us forever.
It's a powerful, stirring, romantic idea, but Mitchell's way of keeping desire alive in a relationship requires an almost Buddhist level of self-awareness. An affair, by contrast, is a far quicker way for a married person to bring desire back into their life (if you're not too particular about the partner's identity). Which brings us to Perel's current book. In The State of Affairs, Perel abandons the theoretical solution and devotes herself to exploring the most common practical solution to the married couple's "deadened bedroom" problem: an affair with someone else.

In the media, Perel is portrayed as a permissive figure who lets cheaters off the hook of their guilty conscience. The headline of the review of her book in The New Yorker was "In Defense of Infidelity." But reading the book left me with a different impression. Even if Perel thinks that the proliferation of affairs is a predictable side effect of the institution of marriage, she's keenly aware of the finest nuances of the betrayed partner's suffering. She never once minimizes the crushing pain, the shattering of identity, the shame, and the grief experienced by someone who discovers that their partner lied to them and carried on an erotic relationship with someone else, behind their back.
What sets her apart is that while she places substantial responsibility on the partner who cheated, she doesn't judge that person's emotional state before the affair, and isn't interested in a moral debate about fidelity. In her view, the greatest hypocrisy isn't the double life of the cheating partner, but that of the society we live in — a society that, on one hand, sanctifies decades-long monogamy, while at the same time refusing to allow an open, realistic discussion of the nature of desire and sexuality. The result is millions of broken couples and millions of people who feel they've failed at one of the most important civic and personal tasks there is — because of their own weak character, rather than because the playing field itself is tilted.
The second thing that sets Perel apart is her belief that working through an affair can actually improve a marriage. In the book, she describes — persuasively, and with a wealth of clinical examples — couples who recovered from infidelity and wove a relationship that was better, more authentic, and more sexually satisfying than the one they'd had originally. In one of the book's most fascinating chapters, Perel illuminates the topic from this unconventional angle: "Many of the couples I see are ashamed to admit the intense erotic arousal that sometimes follows the discovery of an affair. 'How can I desire someone who betrayed my trust? I'm so angry at you, but I want you to hold me.' And yet, the need to physically connect with the person who abandoned us is surprisingly common. Eros doesn't harmonize neatly with our rational parts. In his book The Erotic Mind, sexologist Jack Morin identifies the four cornerstones of eroticism. 'Longing — yearning for what doesn't exist — comes first.' In light of this, we can understand why the anxiety of loss triggered in us by betrayal can ignite a fire that, in some cases, had been extinguished for years [...]. There's nothing like the erotic gaze of the third party to challenge our domesticated perceptions of one another."
I chose this quote because it illustrates why, from my perspective as a couples therapist working in the emotionally focused tradition, even if one can disagree with some of Perel's views (and I'll get to that in future posts), her new book carries enormous importance. The great benefit of The State of Affairs lies, first and foremost, in creating a serious, in-depth conversation about affairs and infidelity — rather than a moralizing, superficial one. Our silence as a society around this subject intensifies the suffering of betrayed partners, who find themselves alone with their shame and pain at exactly the moment they most need warmth and support. At the same time, the silence and hypocrisy surrounding the sexual difficulties of committed relationships isolate all of us, and in doing so, they improve the very conditions in which affairs are born.
Personally, like Perel perhaps, I love working with couples trying to recover from an affair. Ten years ago, my father spent several months teetering between life and death in the intensive care unit at Tel Hashomer hospital. Even though he didn't make it out, and even though those months were a nightmare, I remember the medical staff on that ward very fondly. And I also remember the special aura that surrounded them, in my eyes — people who work right along the seam between life and death. An intensive care unit felt to me like the physical edge of the universe, that literal edge marked on ancient maps, from which everything slips off into the infinite. Working with couples trying to climb out from under the rubble of an affair has, for me, a similar dimension. These couples' love has reached the edge. Some of them will slip into the infinite, and some will manage to find their way back to life. Whether they come back together or apart, the period in which partners confront the discovery of betrayal can be a singular time in a relationship — a rare moment of truth and honesty that's hard to reach without an existential threat.
To all these brave people, who give me the privilege of walking alongside them on the edge of this abyss of a relationship, I dedicate this current series of posts, which, inspired by Perel's new book, will deal with various aspects of affairs and infidelity. And if your life has been dramatically affected by an affair or betrayal, and you'd like to tell me about it, I'd love to hear from you.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




