Going into Therapy: When the "Problematic" One in the Relationship Is the One Who Starts to Change
Updated: Oct 22
Gaps in emotional processing can lead to a tense relationship dynamic, in which each side is certain they're the "normal" one — and the other is the problem. But what happens when one side in the relationship goes into therapy, and the balance is disrupted?
Hagit (a pseudonym), 40, thinks she had bad luck marrying a woman on the spectrum. In her view, there's no other explanation for the behavior of Dana, her partner, besides some undiagnosed neurological disorder — because Dana "just acts like a robot." Hagit, by contrast, describes herself as "someone who's super connected to her feelings." And indeed, when something overwhelms her or hurts her, there's no missing it: her voice rises, she tears up easily, her body language grows stormy. And the stormier she gets, the more, often, Dana's temperature seems to drop.
There's something appealing in this. Life's challenges often call for a combination of coping strategies. It isn't always especially useful if both partners are aggressive, or if both are passive and accommodating. When a possible war with Iran is announced, you don't need two pale-faced parents staring at the news. It's good if one of them can make dinner as usual and watch a bad Guy Ritchie movie with the kids. There's an advantage — maybe even an evolutionary one — to the fact that people with opposite coping strategies tend to be drawn to each other and form family units together.
Emotionality or connection to emotion
That said, as anyone who's ever been in a relationship knows, the moment the problem isn't external to the couple — like a terrible neighbor, a scandalous teacher, or a tormenting prime minister — but rather one partner experiences the other as the source of their suffering, a collision is created. If Hagit comes home from work, say, needing attention, while Dana is on her phone, things can escalate very quickly. Hagit might say to her: "I need a little attention right now. I need you to put the phone down. I need you to hug me." And Dana might answer, "Sure, one second, I'm coming" — and meanwhile, yet another production of the horror show called "Hagit and Dana" is already underway.
Both Dana and Hagit feel that they represent the normal side of the relationship, while the other one is the problem. From Hagit's point of view, since her emotions show up so clearly in her body, she's certain she's connected to her feelings, and she believes the problem is Dana's emotional detachment. But really, she's confusing emotionality with being connected to one's emotions.
In a similar way, when she cries, she thinks she's being vulnerable, when really she's hurt — and she doesn't let anyone forget it. Being "hurt" is a state of mind that can be the exact opposite of being "vulnerable," and can actually be quite aggressive. Just as tears can be quite aggressive, even though the person shedding them often believes they're being vulnerable — and can't understand why the way they express their feelings isn't being met with compassion.
Dana, too, can think of herself as the rational one — since she deals with situations using logic. What she misses is that fleeing from uncomfortable emotions, at the very moment you're supposed to be feeling them, isn't a rational act at all.

Changing the couple's "script"
Emotions, as I've written here before, aren't decoration. Understanding that when we lose something we're meant to feel sadness; when we're in danger — fear; when someone brings something into our life that we didn't want, or takes from us something that isn't theirs — anger. All these emotional responses are mental health. Fleeing into thoughts as a way to calm yourself down, so as not to encounter emotions like these, is not mental health.
So the starting point is that partners who experience themselves as normal, and their partner as the problematic one, are usually mistaken. Add to that the observation that partners tend to connect with each other when their level of emotional processing is similar. To some extent, you could say that if their processing levels are too different, they can't really attract each other or hold each other's interest over time. No intense emotional connection will form between them if one is genuinely connected to their emotions and the other isn't at all.
Often, at the start of a relationship, partners complement each other in their defenses, regulating each other through those defenses — even if the defenses aren't adaptive, and even if, along the way, they often push each other's buttons. Like Dana and Hagit. But what happens when one of the two starts to develop?
What happens, for instance, if Dana starts going to therapy — because of something that happened at work, like being unable to advance despite her talent, or a deterioration in her conditions? And over the course of therapy, she starts to connect with the wounded child inside her — the one who learned to suppress her own needs so as not to burden her parents, who learned to escape into her own inner world to calm down without leaning on anyone else.
In therapy she gains the tools and the courage to do things differently, and with her therapist's encouragement, she brings these things to Hagit's doorstep. Suddenly, instead of fleeing when Hagit gets angry, she stops and tells her that the behavior isn't pleasant for her. And more than that — she gives Hagit what Hagit had supposedly always wanted: she tells her about her own fears and her own pain.
What happens then? There may be an opening here for Hagit to accept the invitation and rise together with Dana into a relationship with a different level of emotional processing. That happens a lot. After all, we're not identical twins, and often one partner starts developing before the other. But it's also possible that Hagit will stay exactly where she was — and will be shaken by the disruption of the script, whatever its flaws.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




