top of page

Getting Divorced? How to Protect Yourself From the Rabbinical Courts and Private Investigators

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Nov 29, 2018
4 min read

The High Court's ruling on "the cheating wife" will intensify the race to the courthouse and the use of private investigators, but there is a sane way to stay in mediation and divorce with dignity

Last week Israel's democratic public was in an uproar, and rightly so. The High Court of Justice, which is supposed to supervise the rabbinical courts, acted contrary to legal precedent and backed a decision under which the division of property between spouses in a divorce can be based on who is deemed "at fault" for the breakup of the marriage. The move drew many reactions, and here I want to focus on what this ruling may mean for women considering divorce, and for their children.

I'll start with the fact that the High Court's decision intensifies what is known as the "race for jurisdiction." In Israel there are two kinds of tribunals that handle divorce-related matters: the rabbinical courts and the family courts. Any couple seeking a divorce can choose which one to approach. In practice, the spouse who files first decides where the disputed issues will be heard. This is a fateful step, because there can be vast differences between how each tribunal rules on various issues.

The High Court's ruling intensifies the race for jurisdiction because it provides an example of exactly these vast differences. The couple could not agree on how to divide the family home. The case was heard in the rabbinical court, which ruled that the wife would not receive half of the family home because she had been involved with a man who was not her husband. But had she gone to the family court, the outcome would have been the opposite of what the rabbinical court decided and the High Court upheld: the court would have ordered half of the apartment transferred to her. A vast difference.

The rabbinical ruling, now approved by the state's own court, will lead women who have "cheated" on their husbands to make great efforts to keep their cases out of the rabbinical court. They will have to rush to hire a lawyer and open divorce proceedings in the family court, to avoid the husband starting the process in the rabbinate. This haste runs against our interests as a society, and certainly against the interests of children whose parents are divorcing. We want women and men to take part, patiently and in good faith, in a mediation process.

That aspiration underlies the "mandatory mediation" initiative, which seeks to reduce the psychological damage that can result from a legal confrontation between spouses during a divorce. The problem is that women with the sword of the rabbinate hanging over their heads can't risk taking part in pre-litigation mediation, the kind couples enter voluntarily before they approach a court. Women who fear losing all their property may be pushed into a position where they don't give the relationship another chance in couples therapy.

Getting Divorced? How to Protect Yourself From the Rabbinical Courts and Private Investigators - illustration

The other danger in this ruling is the return of private investigators to the personal arena. The ruling is based on the fact that the wife had sex with a man who was not her husband. So this judicial move will bring back to the rabbinical courts the practice of hiring private investigators to follow people, mostly women, violate their privacy and photograph them in order to produce evidence of their behavior.

The violent practice of using private investigators had been in retreat over the past decade thanks to two significant rulings. The first is by Supreme Court President Aharon Barak, which meant that "incriminating" photographs are not always considered admissible evidence because they violate privacy. The second is by High Court Justice Miriam Naor, who made the use of such evidence moot by seeking to send a judicial message that infidelity is not a legitimate consideration in dividing property.

And now, at a peak period of violence against women in Israel, the return of the private investigator looks likely, with all the ugliness, voyeurism and aggression that entails. It's a move that may encourage physical violence against women, and it keeps people who are divorcing from rebuilding their lives and continuing to cooperate as parents for the sake of their children.

Given these harsh implications, I want to stress that there is a solution that lets women stay in the mediation process after all, while reducing the risk to them. I always recommend starting mediation with both sides signing an agreement confirming that even if the mediation blows up, they commit to going only to the family court. You can write it by hand or print it on a page in two copies, then sign them, write the date and put them aside.

In this simple agreement, the spouses state explicitly that they agree the family court will be the sole authority able to hear all matters related to their divorce. They can specify in a few words that this includes child custody and visitation arrangements, alimony and child support, and, because of cases like the one we're discussing, all matters of property and money as well. Some mediators even recommend writing into this agreement that neither spouse will turn to the rabbinical court on the listed issues or claim any jurisdiction other than the one they've agreed on in the agreement they're signing.

I wish you never find yourselves in hard situations, and that we meet at the rabbinate only to dance on the steps.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page