top of page

Fluent Passive-Aggressive: How to Deal With Passive Aggression

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Nov 8, 2018
4 min read

People who act out passive aggression are counting on you to catch the hint. The secret to coping is to ignore the manipulation

One of the most damaging emotional defenses in relationships is passive aggression. It can develop when a person grows up in an environment where every expression of anger, or every attempt to hold a boundary, is met with a very harsh response. The destructive effect of that kind of upbringing is that, as an adult, this person has trouble expressing his (healthy) aggression directly, doesn't take responsibility for the aggressive parts of himself (which exist in every one of us), finds it hard to say "no," and doesn't know how to set a limit.

Because he still needs to protect himself in order to survive, this person develops a range of indirect (passive) ways to express his opposition to events around him that he doesn't like, or to impose on his surroundings the order he wants. The problem is that these methods usually lead the people around him to respond with aggression. On one hand that outcome is welcome to him, because he'd rather have others be the ones identified with aggression, but it also has negative consequences for his social relationships.

Among these methods, passive-aggressive remarks stand out. They include speaking vaguely, blaming others behind their backs, chronic complaining, sarcasm, eye-rolling and mournful hints, what Israelis call "being Polish" (the guilt-tripping, martyred-mother style). To understand how to deal with the remarks of people who suffer from passive aggression, I want to analyze the structure of their verbal communication.

Imagine two friends who've arranged to meet. Adam is waiting for his friend Benny, but Benny is late. If Adam can tolerate his own aggression and speak directly, he'll say to Benny: "Honestly, it kind of annoyed me to have to wait for you." Speaking openly invites a direct response from the latecomer, who can explain himself, apologize or take issue with the facts. Either way, a simple expression of anger like this usually improves the relationship between the two friends and brings them closer.

Now imagine that Adam is passive-aggressive. In that case, when his friend is late he won't be able to express his displeasure openly. Instead he'll open a gap between the surface layer of his words (the text) and the hidden layer (the subtext), and say, for example: "I understand you had something more important to do." Adam is counting on Benny to understand the subtext, the veiled accusation, and to attack him back in response. Benny might say something like: "Why are you always criticizing me? We finally went out to have a good time, why do you have to ruin it?"

That sentence will be Benny's downfall. Adam, who was never comfortable with his own aggression to begin with, has managed to make Benny the aggressive one. And once Benny is the aggressive one, passive-aggressive Adam can hide behind the fact that Benny responded to the subtext and not to the stated part of what was said. Adam's classic passive-aggressive defense in this case would be: "What do you want? Why are you attacking me? What did I even say? All I said was that I understood that if you're late, you must have had something more important to do. It wasn't an accusation at all."

Fluent Passive-Aggressive: How to Deal With Passive Aggression - illustration

How Do You Get Out of This?

There are several things you can do to reduce the sabotage in an interaction with a passive-aggressive person, but in this piece I'll focus on just one principle: don't respond to the subtext, only to the surface of what was said. Staying with our example: if Adam says to Benny, "I understand you had something more important to do," Benny will do well to pretend he doesn't get the hint and doesn't hear the accusation, and to address only what was actually said. For instance, any of the following answers will get him out of the passive-aggressive trap: 1. "Actually, I had something really important to do at the office." 2. "Actually, I didn't have anything really important to do." Or 3: "I didn't follow, what do you mean?"

The third option is my favorite, and I recommend it as the default response to a passive-aggressive attack. Picture the following situations:

1. Passive-aggressive remark: "Are you sure you should order that dessert?"

Subtext: "You're fat, and I disapprove of how you eat."

The right response: "I didn't quite follow, what do you mean?"

2. Passive-aggressive remark: "Okay (eye-roll), do whatever you think best."

Subtext: "You're wrong, and I'm angry that you won't accept my opinion."

The right response: "I didn't follow, what do you mean?"

3. Passive-aggressive remark: "Why are you making such a big deal out of it?"

Subtext: "I feel you're accusing me and it irritates me. I'm not going to apologize; in fact you're making me angry, and it's your problem that you're oversensitive."

The right response: "Sorry, I didn't follow, what do you mean?"

Back to our example: each of these answers ("I had something more important" / "I didn't have anything more important"), and above all the answer "I didn't follow, what do you mean?", leaves the passive-aggressive person with only two possible responses. One is to climb down from the tree, that is, to retract the aggressive part of his statement and say something like: "I didn't mean anything, just, forget it, it was a joke, it's all fine," in other words, to give up the subtext. The other is to take responsibility for the anger and say, assertively, something along the lines of: "I meant that it hurts me that you're late to our meetings every time." That is already a far healthier statement, one you can deal with and that doesn't drive you up the wall.

The Bottom Line

Whenever someone speaks to you in "Polish" and stirs up guilt or another strong negative emotional reaction in you, it's best not to react right away. In the face of passive aggression, the thing to do is not react but think, because if you lose control you fall into the trap the person across from you has set. Remember this, and repeat it from now until the next family meal: "I didn't follow, what do you mean?"


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page