Every Family Makes One Basic Mistake: It Crowns a Scapegoat
A tribute to the revolutionary family therapist Salvador Minuchin, who has died at 96
This week the provocative family therapist Salvador Minuchin died at the age of 96. Minuchin's central contribution to family therapy was to shift attention away from the "identified patient" — that black sheep every member of the family agrees is the sole, root cause of its troubles. The identified patient isn't the problem, Minuchin argued; the real problem is the web of relationships and roles running through the whole family, in which the "sheep" is just one (thankless) part. Minuchin also challenged the traditional definition of the family therapist as a passive listener, and encouraged family therapists to challenge and provoke their patients.
In a review she wrote of Minuchin's book "Family Healing: Tales of Hope and Renewal from Family Therapy," Sophie Freud, Freud's granddaughter, described him this way: "He jokes, cajoles, confronts, scorns, praises, argues, apologizes — turning himself into a magician, a beloved uncle, or a bullying authority figure, in order to help family members break out of a rigid pattern that causes them pain."
And of course there's an Israeli angle too: Minuchin was born and raised in San Salvador, Argentina, but immigrated to Israel and served as a physician in the IDF. When his service ended he went to New York to study child psychiatry. After completing his studies he returned to Israel to work as a child psychiatrist. But in 1954 he went back to the United States to study psychoanalysis with Harry Stack Sullivan. After finishing his psychoanalytic training, Minuchin worked as a child psychiatrist at a school for juvenile delinquents in the U.S. During this period he developed structural family therapy (also known as the systemic theory of family therapy). Observing the delinquent boys and working with their families led him to the revolutionary insight that there was nothing inherently wrong with these children — rather, "every family has a scapegoat." Over the years he visited Israel more than once, taught here, and trained many students.
Since he was a clever, witty man full of life, I thought the best way to honor him would be to share some of his characteristic quotes. The quotes below are translated from an interview he gave to the site psychotherapy.net in 2011.
"When they train you to be a therapist, they train you to be kind and supportive. My colleagues and I felt there was too much support, too much kindness, and that patients weren't being challenged enough. We felt there should be an alarm that wakes the person up and says, 'Wait a minute. Let's try to understand what you're doing. Isn't there another way you could act?' And that direction came from my Argentine background. Desafío, 'the challenge,' is an elemental concept in Argentina — you fight with knives. In therapy, that translates into challenging the patients' basic ideas."
"The desire to challenge patients came from the understanding that when families arrive for therapy, they arrive with a basic mistake. They're wrong in the sense that they're certain about their analysis of the situation. They come to family therapy with a mistaken sense of certainty. They've 'identified' which family member is the sick one, the problem, and they're sure that the whole family's problem lies in the pathological way that member talks, behaves, thinks, or feels."

"Obviously these families are wrong. They prefer to think the problem is intrapsychic — something wrong inside the mind of this family member, whom the others have identified as 'the sick one.' It's between him and himself. But we show them that this very belief is part of an overall transaction among family members, and that's the outlook of the systemic approach to family therapy."
"I, probably because I'm old, use the concept of personal responsibility toward others a great deal. And I rely on an optimistic view according to which a person can be responsible toward others because they have resources they're not aware of. I always tell people, 'You're richer than you think. You don't know it because you've developed a narrow behavioral specialty. You specialize in one style of behavior, but I know you have other options.' People have other options they simply don't use."
"And that's the basis that lets me question the certainty with which people declare, 'I'm completely fine, and the rest of my family is completely fine — the problem is my son, he's the only delinquent one.' I start from the assumption — systemic therapy theory starts from the assumption — that isn't about certainty, but about possibilities. All five family members, say, are involved in a set of transactions that creates the family dance they bring with them into the clinic. Systemic theory invites you to think of the behaviors within the family as a field of possibilities. And a field of possibilities isn't a map drawn in advance. If someone in the family takes this path, you'll arrive at that place. But they could also take the other path. I always come back to Borges's idea that 'when you reach a crossroads, go both ways.' To me, that's an important statement about the fact that a person is a multifaceted being, full of possibilities. Because the path you did take is maybe the one that made you an expert in a certain behavior, but the path you didn't take is also part of your life experience."
"Many theorists talk about attachment. Sue Johnson is one of them. And Bowlby said that the relationship between infant and mother forms a prototype for how we cope with people in important relationships later on. According to this view, the roots of my relationship with my wife, after 58 years of marriage, lie in my own relationship as an infant with my mother. That doesn't make sense to me. The idea comes from the psychoanalytic notion that childhood creates a model that repeats itself. But in my opinion it only repeats itself up to a point. And then it changes. And then it changes again. The idea that we need to look at our upbringing in order to understand our adulthood, and our later adulthood too, doesn't make sense to me."
"It's true that we're a product of our parents' upbringing. When I tell someone, your parents gave you this kind of lens to help you see the world — in particular, a limited view — that's true. But it's only one of the models you have. Because after that you got married, and you have a wife. And how many years have you been married now...?"
"My first childhood ambition was to sing tango. Then I wanted to be a poet. Then I wanted to be a playwright. I read a lot of plays, and I wrote three, but I'm not really good at it. I started too late. Once I wrote a play that I showed to the director of the National Theatre in London. He read it, and he told me, 'Sal, you're such a good family therapist. Why do you need to be a mediocre playwright?' And that was the end of my career as a playwright."
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




