Do Men's Negotiating Skills Give Them an Edge in Divorce Mediation?
Updated: Oct 22
We raise girls to be good and boys to be the best. That difference gives men an advantage in divorce mediation, and because of it, women fail to stand up for themselves and agree to arrangements that don't serve them
Imagine you are mediating a dispute between two people from very different cultures. Let's call them A and B. A grew up in a culture where the highest social value is being nice and well liked, and where even adults go on striving to be "good kids." B, by contrast, comes from a culture that worships success, where children learn from an early age to aim for first place at any cost.
You are not a naive mediator. On the contrary, you know both cultures well. You know that A was taught that lying is impolite, and that when he does lie, it is usually a white lie, the kind that helps others feel a little better about themselves. You also know that B was raised to believe that the ends justify the means, and that when he hesitates to lie in order to get what he wants, the people around him hint that "everyone is a hustler."
Now here is the question: how should what you know shape the way you treat the parties? Will you give A's statements and B's statements the same weight? Are you supposed to assume they are equally matched when it comes to negotiating?
I believe not. And yet, in the situation that plays out daily at mediation tables across the country, many mediators assume there is no difference between A's negotiating abilities and B's, and that any difference that does exist is individual and belongs to the particular couple.
So who are A and B, and which cultures do they belong to? I assume you have already guessed that they are men and women. When it comes to the law, men and women come from radically different cultures: there is an enormous gap between the number of arrests of men and of women in every category of crime except prostitution. This finding recurs not only around the world but within every ethnic group and throughout all of recorded history for which statistics exist. The more serious the crime, the smaller women's share of arrests. For white-collar crimes, the proportion of convicted women falls in some countries to just about four percent.
When women turn to crime, they do so for different reasons than men. A comprehensive study from Australia and New Zealand found, for example, that women imprisoned for fraud often did it because they had trouble refusing family members' material demands, wanted to look like the perfect mother or the perfect wife, had to support their families (especially after divorce), or wanted to express love for their partners through material gifts. Men's motivations were different: greed, gambling debts, a wish to save a failing business, and increasing their influence over others.

These findings raise plenty of thoughts, but in this column I want to focus on a single question: what do they mean for divorce mediation? In an earlier piece I pointed to gender differences that shape how men and women represent themselves in mediation. There I argued that in many families women are in charge of the emotional conversation, while men are appointed to handle the family's negotiations with the outside world, from the mechanic to the landlord to the bank. One result of this division of labor is that many women arrive at the mediation table armed with plenty of emotional arguments, at exactly the moment when the other side has minimal motivation to make sure they feel emotionally satisfied. Meanwhile, many men arrive at the table after years of sharpening their negotiating skills. And so the mediation room often fosters the illusion that men are rational and women are emotional.
Taking all these points into account, the question to ask is this: are men at greater risk than women of acting in bad faith in divorce mediation? And if so, what can be done to make the process healthier?
To answer, I want to turn to the feminist psychologist Carol Gilligan, who explained how deeply men's and women's conceptions of morality are shaped by the patriarchal context in which they grow up. She showed that men build a mental map that arranges interpersonal relationships in a hierarchy, and judge the morality of an act against abstract principles of justice. Women, by contrast, judge the morality of actions by what they contribute to interpersonal bonds, to caregiving, and to responsibility toward others.
In short, we raise girls to be good and boys to be the best. We reward girls for being good girls, meaning that they are kind to their little brother, do their homework, and don't lie. At the same time, we reward boys for being the best, meaning that they achieve the most impressive results and reach the top of the pyramid. In this way we steer girls toward more moral behavior, while hinting to boys that the ends justify the means.
When a man and a woman who have gone through this patriarchal boot camp arrive at divorce mediation, they may find themselves in a problematic, lopsided situation that harms them both and their children. The man no longer sees the woman as part of his family unit, and he may feel that any means is acceptable to "beat" her in the divorce agreement, as if it were a sports competition. The woman won't stand up for herself because she recoils from the prospect of looking like a "bad girl" in her husband's eyes or the mediator's. A mediator who fails to consider that the man and woman before them are not Adam and Eve but creatures whose thoughts, behavior, and conscience have been shaped by social and political forces may steer them toward an agreement that doesn't truly reflect their resources and doesn't meet their needs.
On the mediator's side, the solution also lies in sharpening the gender perspective while managing the mediation, in a way that shows up in practical measures that help the parties proceed transparently and voice their needs freely. But the greater responsibility is ours, as a society: to raise boys who fear failure less, who are exposed to less humiliation and contempt when they fail to climb to the top of the patriarchal tree, and who can realize their moral potential from a position that is connected to others and takes responsibility for them, rather than one that tries to defeat them.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




