top of page

Craving the Real Thing: How the Memoir Became the Only Genre That Doesn't Lie to Us

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Dec 25, 2025
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

When our feeds are full of blissful influencers touring Italy, having plenty of sex, and eating avocado toast, but real life is a struggle — personal storytelling is the one place where the truth still gets told

Looking back on this year, it seems to me that more than ever before, the world is dividing into the heartless and the heart-having. One trend that bears this out is the flourishing of a literary genre with a name that's notoriously hard to translate: the memoir. What used to be a small shelf in the bookstore is, in recent years, anything but. Memoirs are winning major literary prizes, getting turned into television series, and touching the hearts of millions around the world.

Personally, this year I read Patti Smith's Bread of Angels, Shirley Jackson's Life Among the Savages, Arundhati Roy's Mother Mary Comes to Me, Hannah Gadsby's Ten Steps to Nanette, Salman Rushdie's Knife, Joan Didion's Notes to John, a few more books I can't quite recall at the moment, plus a handful of memoirs I'm old enough that all I remember is that I loved them, nothing more specific — so I read them again.

I'm obviously not the only reader devouring memoirs, or publishers wouldn't keep putting them out. To understand this boom, it helps to be clear on the difference between an autobiography and a memoir. An autobiography is usually an attempt to map out an entire life, from birth to adulthood, in chronological order and with an eye to historical accuracy. A memoir makes no such claim to tell "the whole truth" or "the whole story."

If an autobiography tries to be a map of the whole life at its center, a memoir is a hike along one particular trail within it. It zeroes in on a specific stretch of time, a single relationship, or a particular theme — coping with grief, a spiritual journey, a parent-child relationship.

That's also why writers can produce several memoirs over a lifetime. Daniel Mendelsohn, for instance, could write one memoir about searching for relatives lost in the Holocaust (The Lost) and an entirely different one about his relationship with his father, refracted through a reading of the Odyssey (An Odyssey) — both highly recommended. And Patti Smith's latest memoir is hardly her only one, either.

In Search of "the Real Thing"

What's driving this hunger for personal stories? One good reason is that our very notion of "history" — and of who gets to speak — has finally shifted, even if painfully slowly. Where the microphone once belonged only to generals, statesmen, and victors, today we not only recognize that everyone has a story worth hearing, but the memoir has also become a tool of cultural repair: it lets groups once pushed to the margins — women, minorities, communities whose voices were silenced or distorted — step into the spotlight and tell history through subjective experience.

I'm sick of saying it, but there are two more reasons this boom is happening right now, and why we readers are drawn to it like a magnet: we live in a time of extreme volatility, of "fake news," awash in images. It's only natural that the human psyche goes looking for an anchor. We're craving "the real thing." We want proof — proof that survival is possible, that the human spirit is resilient, and that even out of brokenness, meaning can be built.

In a class I recently taught on the memoir genre, I wanted to dwell on the "contract" signed between writers and readers. A memoir isn't just gossip or voyeurism; it's a survival guide. When we read a memoir, what we're really asking the writer is: "How did you get through this? What did you learn?" As someone currently writing a memoir of my own, these questions occupy me not only as a psychologist and a reader, but as a writer too. Where's the line between a private diary and a work that has value for a reader? I think the answer lies in that same principle: survival, and the processing of it.

Craving the Real Thing: How the Memoir Became the Only Genre That Doesn't Lie to Us - illustration

A Weapon in the Fight for Sanity

In the session I led, we looked at three exemplary cases. We read a passage from the raw, bleeding — and tragicomic — truth of Jeanette Winterson's Why Be Happy When You Could Be Normal?. The title itself, if I remember correctly, is a direct quote from her adoptive mother, a fundamentalist religious woman, uttered the moment Winterson came out of the closet. Winterson writes from the wound of a repressed sexual identity and a childhood in the shadow of a harsh, almost monstrous mother.

But the book isn't just an indictment; it's testimony to literature's power to heal. For her, as for so many writers early in their lives, books were the rescue. Her writing is sharp and uncompromising, and it teaches us that the ability to retell your own story is the ultimate act of survival for the individual against a crushing force.

We also read Natalia Ginzburg, who offers in Family Lexicon a completely opposite model, one that teaches us a masterclass in restraint. Ginzburg writes against the backdrop of harrowing historical and personal drama, set during the rise of fascism in Italy, and if you haven't read it, I genuinely recommend putting your phone down and going to find this book. Her "I" in the story stays almost transparent, stripped of ego. She doesn't put her own pain center stage; instead she becomes a kind of documentarian, capturing her family members through their own words.

And then there's the formidable Daniel Mendelsohn, whose book The Lost takes the memoir into the territory of literary and historical detective work. In this phenomenal book, Mendelsohn, a scholar of classics, isn't content with the general, hazy memory of the Holocaust. He sets off on a globe-spanning, obsessive journey (what would be the point otherwise) to trace the exact fate — down to the last detail — of six murdered relatives whose stories had until then been shrouded in fog.

For him, the memoir is an attempt to fight forgetting and loss not only through emotion but through intellect and research. Mendelsohn shows us that even when you can't know everything, and even when the story's painful ending is known in advance, the search itself is an act of meaning-making. His writing proves that a story's role is to bridge the unbearable gap between capital-H History and personal tragedy.

What the writers we studied in class — Winterson, Ginzburg, and Mendelsohn — share with the new wave of memoirs being published right now is the understanding that personal story is a weapon in the fight for sanity. Each of them offers us a different path toward hope. For us, Israeli readers trying to find our footing in the fragile reality of 2025, these books are far more than literary entertainment; they're resources of resilience.

Other People's Stories

As I said, these thoughts have been preoccupying me even more than usual lately — not just as a psychologist or a lecturer, but as a writer currently in the thick of writing a memoir of her own. In fact, looking at this very column you're reading right now, I realize this is exactly what I'm trying to do here, "together" with you, week after week: reflecting on the delicate links between one-time lived experience and generalizable psychological knowledge. I keep asking myself — how do you turn the personal into the universal? And how can things that happen in one person's life — mine, or a patient's — echo someone else's story?

I think answering that requires going back to the unbearable gap between image and reality. Yes, yes, we know — but I'll say it again anyway: we live in a visual age, surrounded on social media, in advertising, and on television by images of beauty, happiness, success, and perfection. The endless scroll through our feeds tells us that everyone is about to have sex, everyone is touring Italy, and everyone is eating avocado toast with a fried egg on top — somehow all of this beauty is happening at the exact same moment.

Maybe only therapists, mental health workers, and social workers truly, truly know how different reality actually is. They know that for the overwhelming majority of human beings, life is a constant struggle. Everyone is carrying something: loss, anxiety, loneliness, or a sense of missed chances. The memoir is the place where this truth finally gets said out loud.

Now add to the equation the fact that we've lost something basic in our social structure. We no longer live in tribes. We no longer sit around the fire at night learning from the experience of tribal elders, or even from our neighbors (unless you count learning from a social-media influencer how to make a one-ingredient salad). A lot of the life wisdom that used to pass from person to person has simply been lost.

The memoir repositions us as members of the tribe of humanity. It crosses boundaries of time and place and lets us learn from other people's experience of love, grief, and survival. In bibliotherapy it's been known for years that literature isn't just an escape but a remedy: reading someone else's story lets the psyche process its own pain through aesthetic distance, and find comfort in knowing that suffering is universal.

Working through this genre has opened up another question for me: how do you judge a memoir, aesthetically and critically? The crucial point lies in a shift of the underlying question. When we read fiction, the central question isn't whether to believe it but whether we understood it; but with a memoir, the immediate, decisive question is whether we believe the writer. That trust is the genre's bedrock, and the first test every memoir must pass.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page