top of page

Chapter Two: Why Should Mom's New Partner Get a Say in My Life?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 25, 2024
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Beyond shattering children's fantasy that you'll get back together, bringing new partners into your life confronts them with challenges they never chose. How do you balance your own needs as a couple with the kids' place in the new family equation?

Not every divorced parent is longing for chapter two. Some just crave quiet after the storm of the divorce itself. Others dream of the perfect combination: a new relationship plus a peaceful family. But reality, as usual, is more complicated than that.

For many children, the divorce itself is only the beginning of the crisis. It can be frustrating for parents, but kids whose parents split up may go on clinging, for a long time, to the fantasy that their parents will get back together. Sometimes they pour serious emotional energy into trying to reconnect them. They build elaborate scenarios: "I'll say I forgot something at Mom's, and then Dad will come by just to pick up my bag, and he'll say hi to Mom, and if they happen to be nice to each other, then maybe — just maybe — you can imagine them getting back together."

In other words, they're carrying around something disconnected from reality — not fully grasping the depth of the rupture between their parents, not yet getting that "it doesn't work that way." But their fantasy is real to them, and every lost fantasy comes with grief. A parent's new relationship shatters that fantasy without mercy, and makes the finality of the breakup impossible to ignore.

A Game of Musical Chairs

The second crisis is rooted in children's need to find their place within the new family structure. It's a bit like a game of musical chairs, where suddenly, once the music starts, it turns out there's a new player whose seat right next to one of the parents is already guaranteed. Even if the parents aren't yet living together with the new partner under one roof — even if it's just spending a lot of hours with that parent — and even if the new partner doesn't have children of their own, it's still a major challenge for the kids.

The children have to get used to an intimacy that exists between two people, one of whom is their parent and the other a stranger. To some degree, they also have to accept guidance, rules, and behavioral instructions from someone who isn't their parent. This is part of how some of the myths and folk tales about stepmothers came to exist in the first place. The result, very often, is that children feel like they're being tested in their own home, and a question starts nagging at them: how hard will my parent actually fight for me, and what's my place in this new family constellation?

Some parents adopt a radical stance: "If my kids don't get along with my partner, the relationship is off." As romantic as that position may sound, it's problematic. It hands children an outsized amount of power — as mentioned, since many children already fantasize about their parents reuniting, this stance essentially tells them that if they simply refuse to engage, their parents won't be able to build new relationships at all.

Sometimes we take this stance as parents out of our own ambivalence toward the new partner. But in most cases, even when we're genuinely swept up in the new relationship, letting our children decide the fate of our love life exposes issues of our own — ones worth trying to become aware of.

This stance can sometimes stem from our own guilt toward our kids. If I feel guilty for breaking up their family and for building a new one, I might think: "At the very least, I'll make it up to them by letting them feel like they're the ones in charge." Except children can't actually be in charge. They didn't decide who your first partner would be, and they won't decide who the next one is either.

A Stranger in the Equation

All of this only underscores how important it is to choose your next partner wisely. When you're coming out of a failed marriage, it can feel like the only criterion that matters for a new partner is being noticeably different from the last one. But the truth is that the mental "wanted" ad for the person you'll build a new family with needs to include a few more conditions.

When you're sizing up a new "candidate" for this important role, you need to privately ask yourself whether this partner actually understands what it means to join an existing family. In the heat of falling in love, people tend not to think the implications all the way through. You have to understand that this involves real adjustment on the children's part, and it can come with anger and aggression from them.

Say that after the split, the parents took a cooling-off period and neither one brought strangers into the house. That let the children spend time with each parent separately, and maybe even enjoy some quality time with them that hadn't existed while the parents were still together. The moment a new partner enters the picture, the children suddenly find themselves constantly with Mom and her partner, or Dad and his partner, and they're constantly having to adjust. They're always in the company of a third person who isn't their parent.

Imagine that every single time you were with your kids, some stranger's child was tagging along too, and you had to fold them into every interaction with your own child — not exactly a small thing, right? As the divorced parent, you're facing an ongoing balancing act. What happens when your child misbehaves and your partner gets annoyed? Whose side are you on now? Who are you supposed to please? How do you resolve that?

This is where the importance of a parent's mentalizing ability comes up again — the ability to understand your children's thought processes, to see the world through their eyes. Picture a parent who lives in the center of the country and moves to the far edge of it with a new partner. If that parent has a young child, they can, technically, force the child to come along every time they visit the new family nest way out there.

And this is exactly where it matters for that parent to stop and ask themselves: Am I really going to force my child to travel an hour and a half each way to that woman's house? What are the odds this actually works out? What message is my child receiving? Are they getting the message that they don't really matter that much, because my starting assumption is simply that they'll manage? Maybe they will manage — but what will they take away from it? Maybe my child will think: "There's a woman there who takes care of her own kids — that's why she's the one staying put and not moving to the center with him — and as far as I'm concerned, Dad decided I'm the one who can be dragged around. But why, exactly? Maybe because I matter less?"

One way to cope is to insist on time that belongs only to you and your kids, with no new partners included. Your children haven't become your new partner's children. If you ignore this, you'll pay for it in the quality of the relationship, even if it looks, on the surface, like the kids have adjusted. It's your responsibility as a parent to make sure your children are genuinely at peace with the new situation, and not just choking down every frog you feed them.

If, from your children's point of view, you're sacrificing their needs for the sake of your new relationship, it will eat away at them from the inside, and eventually that will show up in your relationship with them too. And rightly so — because choices like that damage children's trust in their parents, and undermine their confidence that their parents truly see them, and that they still matter.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page