Can Your Marriage Survive an Affair?
Updated: Oct 22
A "revival affair" is meant to jolt an indifferent partner out of their slumber — and it's a marriage that can actually recover
If you're having an affair, you're probably relieved the holiday is almost over. Holidays are a hard stretch for relationships — official ones, and unofficial ones too, if they exist. There's a limit to how many times a person can go to the bathroom with their phone without arousing suspicion. It's no accident that requests for divorce always spike right after the holidays. The connection makes sense: an affair whose intensity builds against the backdrop of a holiday's family closeness and tradition is liable to explode, which can end up breaking the marriage apart.
But not every affair that comes to light destroys a relationship. All over the internet you'll find various statistics claiming that a wife's affair endangers a marriage more than a husband's, and so on, and there are several sociological reasons one could point to for that — for instance, the possibility that the stigma a betrayed man faces is harsher than the one a betrayed woman faces. But from my vantage point as a couples therapist, and also as a divorce mediator, there's a far more useful way to classify affairs, one that helps us understand which couples have a good chance of recovering and which don't. I divide them into three types:
The Dead Man Walking affair.
The Coup de Grâce affair.
The Revival affair.
I've deliberately given these extreme names, because a relationship conducted in secret, when at least one partner has a known, significant, binding romantic relationship, is an event that takes place at the very edge of human experience.
The "Dead Man Walking" Affair
So what is a "Dead Man Walking" affair? This is, in effect, the "classic" affair — the one reflected in old jokes ("why is it dangerous for men to fall asleep ten minutes after sex? because by then they're already driving home") and in TV dramas. The genre's most prominent hero is Don Draper, from "Mad Men." These are people — sociologically, mostly men — who struggle to develop real, full intimacy, and the affair actually allows them to enjoy the experience of connection without risking too much closeness. In effect, the wife and the secret lover function as each other's boundary. The lover, obviously, limits the emotional closeness that can develop between the man and his wife. But the wife, in practice, also limits how much intimacy can develop between the man and his lover, because thanks to her, he never builds a daily shared life with the lover, with all the intimacy that entails.
Someone who has an affair for these reasons is usually a serial type (typically characterized by a withdrawing defense style as well). If you've had the misfortune to fall for someone like this, and you find yourself alone on the roof on Shabbat and holidays, I'd recommend not counting on spending next Passover together. If you're married to someone like this and you've discovered the affair, your chances of recovering depend on how much work you're willing to put in, and on your patience. The odds of success are not huge. The emotional difficulties that brought your partner to this place carry real weight. It's possible that deep down your husband is driven by a fear of being left alone or abandoned, and there's a good chance he sees himself as unworthy of love. Couples therapy alone may not be enough for you. In a case like this, you also need a bit of a miracle. Of course, that doesn't mean you have to separate — marriage provides couples with a great deal beyond emotional intimacy — but you should know what you're up against.
The "Coup de Grâce" Affair
The "coup de grâce" affair, by contrast, is a completely different matter — almost the opposite. This is the affair of someone who actually is capable of intimacy and wants it, but has given up on the possibility of getting it from their official partner. I don't mean to say they're aware of this — and this absolutely happens to women too. If they were aware of it, they might dissolve the marriage instead of betraying their partner's trust. It's also possible that if they were more self-aware, the problem could have been addressed and the marriage saved. It's also possible they entered the relationship with a low capacity for intimacy, but over the years that capacity grew, and they started wanting a relationship with a higher level of intimacy. Either way, once the affair is a fact, you could say they feel their partner is no longer giving them the love they need. Since they're not able to say this — because it isn't yet fully conscious — they show it through their behavior instead.
An affair like this is good news for the secret lover, and bad news for the husband or wife, because an affair born of despair often predicts the end of the relationship. Whether or not the secret partner becomes the official one, the person having the affair isn't at high risk of hurting their next partner in a similar way — but only on the condition that they start to know themselves, whether through therapy, meditation, or whatever works for them, and learn to express their needs to the next person they love.

The "Revival" Affair
So if these first two kinds of affairs spell doom for a marriage, what can we actually build on? The third type, the "revival affair," is the daily bread of the hardest couples therapy cases. Very often, couples who come to therapy after an affair has come to light are actually dealing with this kind of affair. In its destructive way, this affair is almost the inverse of the "coup de grâce" affair. In couples therapy, and specifically in Emotionally Focused Therapy, we see the attachment needs of each partner as the foundation of the relationship. So this approach focuses, among other critical elements of healing, on the message the offending partner was trying to send their official partner through the affair (of course, for the therapy to succeed, the affair itself has to end unambiguously). An emotionally focused couples therapist will see an affair of this kind as a "protest affair," meant to protest against a partner who has long been emotionally unavailable, unresponsive to the partner who ultimately betrayed them, and not emotionally engaged in their life even before the crisis.
This, too, is of course an unconscious act, with very severe consequences. It would certainly have been better if the partner who turned outward from the marriage had known how to say how hard things were for them in the relationship, and had brought their original partner to couples therapy or some other way of addressing their problem. But the awareness apparently wasn't there, and in the moment, this affair is a kind of attempt — hurtful, sometimes devastating, yes — to actually pull the official partner closer to the partner having the affair. This can be hard to grasp at first, but it can create a dramatic turning point, and set the relationship on a path of repair and healing, once it's understood that the person who had the affair (often someone whose defense style is pursuing) feels hurt or abandoned by their official partner. From a couples-therapy perspective, an affair of this kind is read as an extreme attempt to wake a partner from their slumber, to stir their jealousy, and to check whether they still care about the relationship at all.
An affair like this doesn't hold much promise for the secret lover — but if the married couple comes to couples therapy, they have a good chance of recovering from the crisis. Of course, the road is long, and a great many boxes of tissues get emptied along the way. I don't mean to give the impression that someone who betrayed their partner can expect couples therapy to make life easy. The path to recovery has to run through the offending partner's willingness to touch the very core of their hurt partner's experience. These are broken hearts, and it takes patience, courage and faith to put them back together. The hearts may never become fully whole again, but as Leonard Cohen wrote, "there is a crack in everything, that's how the light gets in."
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




