Being "Monogamish": How Open Relationships Can Actually Help a Marriage
Maybe an open relationship beats a divorce? The fourth and final piece in the series
"My husband and I have problems like any couple, but I still smile when I see him walk into a room, and we still hold hands when we walk down the street. For the past seven years we've been 'monogamish.' It started with something like, 'If you ever cheat on me and it's a one-time thing, I'd rather not know.' Then, for my husband's 40th birthday, we had a threesome with a friend. And in that situation, when I saw him at the moment of truth, I didn't feel the jealousy I'd always been afraid of. We have no doubt that our relationship comes first, and just knowing we have the option to try something a little different now and then is enough to make him feel like a sex symbol (and I'm the main one who benefits!). I'm personally not that into sex without feelings or affection, so my own adventures outside the relationship have been fairly limited. We haven't told our families, and not more than a few friends. I don't want to deal with other people's judgment."
This quote was published about five years ago in a column by sex columnist Dan Savage, who coined the term "monogamish" — which, in Hebrew, sounds even better than it does in English. The term describes a lifestyle that's mostly monogamous but allows for some opening of the relationship, with the consent of both partners (or more). In the essay that launched the idea, Savage argued that we assume every form of open relationship is doomed to fail, simply because we only ever hear about the attempts that actually do fail. If a marriage falls apart because of an affair, or because a third party slipped in through the back door, we're bound to hear about it. But we almost never get to hear about happy couples who aren't monogamous. Not because they don't exist, Savage argued, but because they keep quiet about it — afraid we'll treat them as dangerous sex addicts on the fast track to divorce court.
The claim that opening up a relationship can be a good way to save a marriage is essential if we're going to wrap up our discussion of Esther Perel's book The State of Affairs, to which I've already devoted three columns. Perel has always seen acknowledging desire's wild nature as the solution to problems within a couple. "Don't get me wrong," Perel asks, "non-monogamous relationships aren't a cure for every wound, and they aren't protection against infidelity either. But when I see people suffering, forced into decisions that make life harder for everyone involved, I at least want to be able to raise the possibility of opening up their marriage. [...] The idea that you can love one person and have sex with another chills us to the bone. We're afraid that the moment one boundary is crossed, all the walls will come crashing down. And that really can happen. But as too many people are discovering, monogamous marriage is a broken reed to lean on. What's more, I don't want to go along with illusions. Too many people pretend they're working to reignite their passion. They like the idea, but they don't actually want to deal with the reality. What they want is the family, the friendship, or the life they've built together; they don't actually want to tear each other's clothes off. When the writing is already on the wall like that, isn't a non-monogamous solution preferable to divorce? Refusing to even consider that possibility destroys far too many caring partnerships and happy, stable families."

The big question, on the face of it, is whether open relationships can work. Savage and Perel both have a great deal of experience, but to my mind, this is really two separate questions collapsed into one, and each has a different answer. From the couples I've met over the years, I've learned that open relationships can work. As in the quote I opened this piece with, it can work when the opening of the relationship happens with full consent, with the understanding that the couple's bond is the most important emotional and sexual relationship in both partners' lives, and when the agreement gets updated as needed. On this much, I agree with both Savage and Perel.
But is opening up a relationship a good solution for a relationship that's lost its sexual spark? Here is where I part ways with Perel. My background as an emotionally focused couples therapist obviously shapes my view here. I believe that people who open up their relationship out of a shared sexual outlook — one that manages to celebrate their eroticism even while bringing one third party or another into bed — belong to one group. That's a very different group from the one occupied by more "ordinary" people, who turned their desire toward others only after losing the erotic connection to their own partner.
People like that (sometimes called "vanilla"), who didn't arrive at the monogamish format out of a secure relationship but out of a broken one, will, in my assessment, have a hard time finding in an open relationship a long-term solution to a marriage that's lost its passion. Someone whose thing is really plain old monogamy, not monogamish, might manage to hold that arrangement together for a while, because it gives him both hot sex and a stable relationship again. But deep down, I believe, in most cases he'll keep looking for someone who can offer him the whole package. And when he finds that someone — who wants to have sex with him and also wants to spoon with him all night afterward — he'll finally tear apart the scarecrow called his marriage.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




