Are You Wasting Your Time in Therapy? Psychologist Leslie Greenberg Thinks So
Updated: Oct 22
A special interview with Leslie Greenberg, one of the founders of emotionally focused therapy, who explains why it isn't enough to understand your original pain — you also have to feel it in order to get rid of it. Part one
Insight is therapy's siren song. The mermaids of psychotherapy sing out their sweet-voiced insights, and they often tempt me — both as a therapist and as a patient — to leap after them off the therapeutic ship, lose my bearings, and drown. It's true that the first gift psychology ever gave humanity was insight, but anyone familiar with psychodynamic therapy knows that only very rarely does insight lead to deep, lasting psychological change.
That frustration reached a peak for me last week, when I had the privilege of going through an advanced training in emotionally focused therapy with Leslie Greenberg, a Canadian psychologist born in Johannesburg, one of the world's leading psychotherapy researchers and one of the chief original architects of this therapeutic approach. I'm not exaggerating when I say I've never learned so much in so short a time as I did in Greenberg's training.
Before Greenberg got on a plane to go train lucky therapists elsewhere in the world, he agreed to sit down with me for an interview that I'll be drawing on in this series of columns to introduce his revolutionary therapeutic approach — and I'll start with the research-backed insight that insight itself isn't actually the goal of psychotherapy.
What don't we understand about insight?
"Well, our biggest mistake is the belief that insight leads to change. Insights really are helpful to us, but they're not the ultimate way of creating change in a client."
Can you give me an example?
"A person might be aware that they're sensitive to criticism because their father was very critical, or they might know they're sensitive to situations in which they feel lonely and abandoned because they lost their mother when they were young. Within a relationship, they might suddenly feel lonely and abandoned because of something their partner said, and believe they feel this way because of their partner, and blame them for it. But arriving at the insight that this pain is rooted in a childhood sensitivity, and that the pain isn't actually caused by what their partner did, can help them manage these situations in a more regulated way. In that sense, psychological insight is helpful to them.
"The limitation is that even if you understand the historical source of your reactions, and even if you learn to manage them better, the real problem remains: you're still extremely sensitive to situations of feeling lonely and abandoned, or to criticism, as in these examples. In other words, the basic emotional response is still there, and the insight you gained didn't actually lead to a change in that emotional response."
What's the model of change in emotionally focused therapy?
"The goal of emotionally focused therapy is to change the unhelpful, or excessive, emotional response that haunts clients and makes it hard for them to live their lives properly. The best way to do that is to actually feel that old pain — you need to feel it to heal it. The change model behind emotionally focused therapy has been extensively researched, and what we find is that in order to achieve deep, consistent change in clients' emotional state, we need to help them feel that ancient, painful sensation that was never fully experienced to begin with.
"Except that we help them experience that pain through a structured process that produces a new emotional experience, one that changes the brain's encoding of the old emotional experience. According to our model, the best way to change a difficult, painful emotion is to create a process in which the painful emotion is experienced in a way that naturally and immediately gives rise to a different emotion.
"What you need to understand is that some of our emotions move us to approach another person or move toward some goal, while other emotions make us withdraw. For example, fear and shame organize us toward escape, or make us want to shrink so the ground will swallow us up. Anger, on the other hand, pushes us forward, to defend our boundaries. Sadness moves us to reach out and ask for help. What this means is that you can't simultaneously flee from fear and shame and also reach out for help — so the emergence of a new emotion actually transforms the previous one."

What happens to the client you mentioned in your first example, the one who's sensitive to criticism?
"In emotionally focused therapy, we understand that we need to work with the fact that he had a very critical father — but we won't stop at that insight alone. The therapist will go back with the client to memories of the way his father shamed and humiliated him, and will help him re-experience the wish to disappear and the tight, contracted feeling of shame in his body. After we activate that burned-in memory, we'll ask the client what he needs when he feels this pain, or what that painful feeling actually requires. If the feeling is shame, the client might realize he needed validation, or that he needed to feel valued as a child.
"The point is that the moment you truly feel worthy — that you deserve to be valued, and often you need a therapist right there with you in order to feel that — your emotional brain starts working: 'I deserve to feel validated, and I actually never got what I deserved.' Then a new stage of the process begins, in which you're no longer experiencing that trapped pain, but anger instead.
"The structured, safe process in which you experienced the original pain led your emotional brain to generate a healthy, assertive anger — not blaming rage, not aggression, but healthy anger over not having received the validation you needed as a child, say, and that you deserved. If that anger is born out of a therapeutic process that first led you to feel the shame or sadness that has haunted you your whole life, then this fresh anger will transform your original shame. And ultimately, you'll come out of this process with a genuinely new sense of yourself."
What would this change look like for the client who felt terrible every time his wife criticized him?
"He would stop experiencing that harsh internal reaction to his partner's criticism, and would start to feel a greater sense of self-worth and greater inner resilience. When his partner asks him, 'Did you take care of that thing today?' he won't feel that familiar pit in his stomach anymore, and he won't feel that same intense, primary surge of anger. It won't be a slow process that runs through thought and interpretation — he simply won't feel anything special, and certainly not with the intensity he used to know. So he'll be able to simply tell his partner, 'I haven't gotten to it yet.'"
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




