top of page

Anger and Pain vs. Fear and Sex: What Should Couples Therapy Actually Look Like?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
May 2, 2024
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

The differences between two leading schools of emotion-focused couples therapy — one built around uncovering vulnerability, the other treating anger as a legitimate emotion in its own right — reveal two very different ways of understanding romantic relationships, and how to treat them clinically.

Last month, Dr. Sue Johnson passed away — the English-born Canadian psychologist who developed Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) for couples, and one of the most influential voices in couples therapy over the last few decades. Johnson was born in 1947, grew up in a working-class family in Kent, England, and earned her undergraduate degree in English literature from Hull University. She later said that her first insights into relationships came from watching the interactions between her father and other men at the local pub — an emotional intensity she picked up on even as a child. In 1984 she moved to Canada, where she earned her doctorate in education (Ed.D.) from the University of British Columbia.

Around that time, she met Leslie Greenberg, a South African-born Canadian psychologist and the developer of Emotion-Focused Therapy. The two methods' names are nearly identical, but the difference between them hides a story that matters a great deal to therapists and patients alike. Greenberg, whom I've written about extensively in this column, was born in Johannesburg in 1945, and is one of the original architects of the emotion-focused school of therapy as a whole. He originally trained as an engineer before switching to psychology, and earned his doctorate from the University of Chicago, where he studied under Laura North Rice, one of the American psychologist Carl Rogers's most prominent students. As a former engineer, Greenberg tried, as early as the 1970s, to build a mathematical model that could characterize the interactions between therapist and patient. In its early stages, his research focused on empathy, the psychotherapeutic process, the therapeutic alliance, and the role emotions play in human functioning.

What Is EFT, Exactly?

After years of working together, the two approaches split apart. Johnson chose to focus on couples, integrating emotion-focused therapy with the systemic approach of the renowned family therapist Salvador Minuchin, along with attachment theory. Greenberg, meanwhile, kept working with couples too, but put the individual's own healthy emotional processing at the center — along with that individual's ability to respond in a healthy way to a partner's emotional signals. From the outside, watching how much energy Johnson poured into branding her particular variation of emotion-focused couples therapy, you get the sense that her drive to distinguish the two approaches also came from a need to carve out her own territory in the world of therapy.

Connecting to the Original Pain

Johnson's approach centers attachment theory, focusing on the emotional bond between partners on the assumption that strengthening it can resolve conflicts in a relationship and increase satisfaction with it. Her model is built around the idea that emotional responsiveness between partners, and the depth of connection between them, sit at the very center of a romantic relationship — so if there's a problem, it's that center that needs fixing. Greenberg, by contrast, focuses on emotion-focused therapy with individuals first, and extends his work to couples from there. At every step, he emphasizes the importance of bringing the patient into contact with their own emotional pain, in order to replace a maladaptive defensive emotion with an adaptive one. Repairing the patient's own emotional mechanism is the basic goal of his approach with individuals, and the engine of change in his work with couples.

You can get at something of the difference between the two approaches just by looking at how each one treats anger. Sue Johnson sees anger in couples therapy mainly as a secondary emotion, masking deeper primary ones like fear, hurt, or feelings of disconnection and insecurity. In her version of emotion-focused couples therapy, therapists encourage couples to get in touch with these more vulnerable feelings in order to build closeness with their partner. The therapeutic goal is to help partners move from expressing anger to exposing their more vulnerable emotions, which is meant to lead to healing interactions and strengthen the bond between them.

Greenberg, by contrast, starts from the possibility that anger might itself be a perfectly healthy primary emotion — one the patient needs help connecting with and expressing. Take a patient who suffered emotional abuse as a child. At the time, the abuse made him feel shame. That shame was a healthy emotion for its moment, born out of survival mechanisms like identifying with the aggressor. But the tendency to blame himself whenever he's hurt has stayed burned into his mind well into adulthood. He's married to a woman with borderline personality disorder, prone to outbursts of rage. By the time they get to couples therapy, their basic pattern is that during an argument, when his wife attacks him, the husband feels ashamed and disappears into himself.

A therapist working in Greenberg's approach would try, in her work with the husband, to help him connect to his original pain — in a way that lets him access the assertive anger he should have been allowed to feel, as a child, toward the person who hurt him, but couldn't, given the circumstances he was in. In the same way, she'd encourage him to express assertive anger toward his wife when she loses her temper at him. This therapist would expect that anger arising as a healthy response to a boundary violation can actually improve the couple's ability to meet each other's emotional needs. A therapist working strictly by Johnson's book, on the other hand, wouldn't assume there's assertive anger hiding underneath the husband's avoidance that needs to be uncovered to improve the relationship. She would instead encourage the husband to share with his wife the pain he feels when she loses her temper at him, expecting that exposing his own vulnerability would be what brings them closer.

At bottom, the disagreement over anger is really an example of a deeper difference in how the two approaches understand our attachment needs. In an interview I did with Greenberg on this subject, he explained that secure attachment isn't the same thing as love — it's one component in a cluster that together makes up a loving bond. The other two critical ingredients of love, he says, are a person's sense of their own identity, and the level of attraction between them and their partner. We want to feel secure in our relationship, and it matters to us to know our partner "is there for us"; but according to Greenberg, a good relationship also requires that our partner validate our sense of identity and see us in a positive light — including, sometimes especially, in the places where we differ from them.

Johnson's approach struggles to make sense of a situation where a wife tells her husband, "I know you love me, but you just don't see me." When a couples therapist works from an approach that treats relational security as the sole critical condition, she simply has no theoretical tools for a clinical situation like that one — and it's far from rare. In Johnson's emotion-focused couples therapy, a fight is never really about the subject at hand; it's always evidence of a deeper sense of emotional insecurity in the relationship.

Greenberg, by contrast, argues that our very drive for a relationship that not only makes us feel secure but also preserves and builds our separate identity is itself what creates power struggles inside couples. In other words, according to Greenberg, couples often fight not simply because one partner has a need to be right stemming from insecurity in the relationship, as Johnson argues, but because the question of who leads and who's right genuinely matters, and the wish to be right can be rooted in a need to preserve one's identity — even within a good, close relationship. In Greenberg's own words: "That isn't an aspect of secure attachment — it's a separate need that a good relationship is supposed to fulfill."

In other words, Johnson's approach places a single motivation, a single definition of human behavior, above all others: attachment. Greenberg's approach, on the other hand, insists there has to be more than one motivation to explain how we actually behave inside relationships. Johnson builds on attachment theory and emphasizes the idea that a child will explore their surroundings if they feel safe enough to. Greenberg, by contrast, argues that this drive to explore is likely just as hardwired into us as attachment is, because it's critical to our survival — and that a child will explore their surroundings even when they don't feel safe. In his own words: "A secure base is what drives our need to know our romantic relationship will be a safe place for us. But our natural drive to explore is just as much at the root of our need for the relationship to shape our identity in a positive way."

Revolution, or an Elegant Thought Experiment

Another of Johnson's claims that drew criticism is that secure attachment predicts a satisfying erotic life. And it's true that when people experience a drop in attraction, or start an affair, there's often anger at their partner in the picture, or other unresolved emotions, which emotion-focused therapy can surface and heal. But according to Greenberg (and Esther Perel wouldn't argue), attraction and sexual desire are also "an independent root that can't be fully explained by the relationship's other components. Desire is a powerful thing, and people feel it not only when they feel connected and safe with someone else, but in all kinds of different situations — even without secure attachment."

Johnson, incidentally, came around late — and not entirely — to today's more varied understanding of what a relationship can look like. Until fairly recently, it was easy to read her as treating any wish to open up a relationship as evidence of an attachment problem in one of the partners, rather than a legitimate expression of that person's identity.

To fairly weigh how much truth each approach holds, it helps to keep in mind that while Johnson focused on branding her life's work — building an international certifying organization, promoting its importance, and producing books and lectures for a broad public — Greenberg focused on building up the research base. And while Johnson never hesitated to call her approach groundbreaking and revolutionary, Greenberg treats his own theory as an enjoyable thought experiment, one that shouldn't stop us from testing, as scientifically as possible, what actually helps in psychotherapy.

In practice, many therapists working in experiential approaches already blend these different methods. Emotion-focused therapy, emotionally focused therapy, schema therapy, AEDP — all of them hold that emotional healing comes from creating a new emotional experience in the room, not from interpreting emotional experiences on one hand, or from coaching-style interventions on the other. Therapists like these draw on both Greenberg's and Johnson's versions of EFT as they see fit. Some would say that because of the way Greenberg lets his patients come into contact with anger, treating it as a legitimate, natural emotion whose evolutionary job is to move us to action, his approach is especially effective working with women; and that because of Johnson's emphasis on exposing vulnerability, her approach is especially effective working with men.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page