top of page

A Cry for Help: Ofra Ofer Oren's "Crystal and Knives" Is Required Reading — Especially for Therapists

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
May 30, 2024
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

The Sapir Prize winner's book is a scathing indictment that will make every psychologist and therapist squirm in their seat. But once you get past the dreadful shame at the criminal treatment she received from mental-health professionals throughout her life, it's important to keep reading — to understand the price exacted by sexual and emotional abuse within a family

The author Ofra Ofer Oren won the Sapir Prize last year for her book "What Happened to Hagar in Eilat," about the gang rape of a girl named Hagar. Around the book's release, and later following her Sapir Prize win, Ofer Oren gave interviews in which she spoke about the sexual abuse she suffered at the hands of her father, a former squadron commander. Over the years, she has returned to the subject of sexual abuse — including sexual abuse within the family — throughout her prolific writing, and "Crystal and Knives" joins that important shelf of books. It's a slim book, but only seemingly so, because reading it is shattering, and it's very hard to read straight through.

It can be read in many ways, and I read it as breaking down into the following aspects: the events themselves, the family's denial, the effects of the abuse and the denial on her adult life, the failure of psychotherapy, and the responsibility of the people around her.

The Gentleness of the Text Against the Violence of Life

The description of the events themselves is shattering, in the combination between the gentleness of the text — which barely uses adjectives — and the abuse itself: the disturbed, violent acts done to the girl who is the book's protagonist, its narrator, and its author, and their victim. You can see this in the following passage:

"In those days the terror was already taking hold. / The touching. / The narrow hallway, between the wall and the shower, where I get trapped again and again. / When she's not home, he calls me from their bedroom. / But there are no words to say to myself. / A bed (what do people do there, who does things there). / A hug (the rigidity there's no escaping). / A smell (spit-cigarettes-coffee-sweat). / A sound (footsteps. Sandal buckles). / A face (flared nostrils, the pores in reddish skin). / A mouth (the strange smile). / A movement (the flinching hand, the straightening up, the expression that flips into a slap across his face, like a shutter falling). / There are no words to say to myself, no words for the creeping dread, for the alarm, for the chill and nausea, for the trapped terror, for the impossibility, for having nowhere to run, for the freezing body. Will it thaw? Is it possible?"

The violence isn't only the sexual assault itself. Even when the father tells his daughter about his sexual exploits with other women, he's inflicting a violent sexualization on her, at the very same time that he objectifies and humiliates other women — including, of course, his wife, who is the girl's mother, and his mistress ("With the redhead there's passion. She knows how to enjoy herself. And with me… you should know, I can go on for hours").

Reading this book isn't for the faint of stomach, and at times it feels like it should have come with a barf bag — but maybe also with a torch, so you could go outside and protest the criminal abuse taking place in so many homes, every single night, to this day.

A Cry for Help: Ofra Ofer Oren's "Crystal and Knives" Is Required Reading — Especially for Therapists - illustration

Double Post-Trauma

Sometimes, the difference between an injury that destroys a girl's life and one she manages to recover from lies in how her immediate family responds to it. If the abused girl receives meaningful, effective support from her family, the risk of developing post-traumatic disorder and other conditions is smaller. But if the family denies the event, sins by blaming the victim, or specializes in other practices from the gaslighting playbook, the risk is that the girl will suffer a double blow.

Now she's betrayed not only by the person who abused her — who, within the family, should have been someone who protected her — but, when her mother turns her back on her, she's now betrayed by the entire world. A phone call between the narrator and her mother freezes the reader's blood:

"'So what's going on with you and your father? Why do you always have to fight with him?' / 'Do you really want to know?' / 'What? What don't I know?' / 'Okay… that's it… I can't anymore, I can't keep quiet anymore… you know, don't you… you know! That he — Dad — that he abused me.' / 'Abused you? What do you mean? What are you talking about?' / 'You know exactly what I mean, as if you don't know. You know. Abused — touched — while I was asleep — and I woke up — from it — and suddenly saw him there, in the bed.' / 'What? He did that? Also — like that? Also —' / 'What, you didn't know?' / 'How was I supposed to know? Not just with all the… like that? With my own daughter too?' / 'Yes.' / 'And what do you want me to do about it now?' / 'Nothing… nothing… I know you can't…' / 'The steaks are about to burn… I'm hanging up.'"

Abuse that never receives acknowledgment or immediate treatment goes on to destroy a person's adult life. The passage below, for example, doesn't describe the physical violence — which did happen, and happen again — but rather the emotional violence specifically, because the threats of physical violence stand out against an ocean of emotional violence.

"One evening my husband got angry at me again — over what? Over what, exactly? Maybe because the liver dried out when I fried it? Maybe because the tone of my voice grated on him? Maybe because I bought an unnecessary dress? Maybe because I said again that I wanted, despite his firm objection, to enroll in the university's theater department? / 'You want to be an actress? Kissing all kinds of strange men?' / And because he was angry, he decreed: 'Tomorrow you don't get the car.'"

In the End, Everyone Knew

It's possible, and important, to use this text as a springboard for discussing the mechanism by which childhood abuse goes on to sabotage adult life. But personally, as I said, the passages in which Ofer Oren describes her attempts to get help from psychologists are an especially damning indictment. One after another, pieces of evidence are laid out from the crime scene, which again and again turns out to be a small office, with two people in it, a desk, and a box of tissues.

Again and again, chilling behaviors are exposed among people who claim to be helping the victim but who are instead guilty of arrogance, over-analytical interpretation, patriarchal attitudes, condescension, coldness, controllingness, manipulativeness, greed, foolishness, conservatism, and pretentiousness; and above all, above all, a lack of empathy, a lack of basic humanity, and a basic failure to understand the lethal toxicity of sexual abuse within a family. Therapists who interrupt the patient at her most painful moment, instead of giving her, right at that point, the warmth and validation she needs — and justify it in the name of whatever theoretical framework they work within; therapists who, in effect, encourage the patient to repress the wounds of her past and ignore them; therapists who take an almost sadistic, and certainly self-serving, pleasure in the dependency the patient develops on them, and more.

After kissing a great many frogs, the narrator finds one prince who manages to do the complicated yet devastatingly simple thing of validating her suffering and her healing, which until then had been solitary and self-directed. Carol Gilligan would say that this successful course of therapy is an example of how a victim's healing is deeply bound up with the recognition that what she knows is true.

The book closes with an extremely difficult section, in which the narrator comes to understand how many people knew about the abuse she was going through, and about how dangerous her father was — and yet, despite that, did nothing to make sure she got help. The passage carries the heartbreaking title "Did everyone know? Everyone?" And by the time I finished the book, I felt there was nothing that a society — myself included — which neglects its children in so many terrible ways, could possibly say in its own defense.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page