top of page

Who Am I, Really? Looking in the Mirror and Seeing a Different Face

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Feb 27, 2020
4 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Taking the other side's point of view in a family conflict isn't always enough. It also helps to understand how we truly come across to the other members of the family.

In my previous column I compared negotiating with family members to negotiating with terrorists, and proposed a theory: in both cases, the best starting point is an attempt to understand the other side's point of view.

That is true, and it works. But even when we do try to understand the world of the one who is refusing us, we often find it hard to see ourselves from the outside. We can't picture how we look to the partners or children we are trying to influence, and that gets in the way of resolving the conflict taking shape between us.

Say I want my partner to lose weight, or I want my teenage son to quit smoking. Instinctively, I'll try to portray my involvement in their lives in a positive light, just as many people do. We say things like "You know I'm only saying this for your own good." We may get hurt when our offer of help is turned down ("You should be grateful you have a wife who cares so much about your health"), and we bristle: "What do you want from me, to just sit on the sidelines and watch you kill yourself?"

Let me go back to the analogy of the terrorist who hijacked a plane. The family member is the terrorist, and the cooperation we are trying to secure (the weight loss, or giving up cigarettes) is the hostages we are trying to free from his hands. If the person negotiating with the terrorist says, "I'm only telling you this for your sake, to help you. You should be glad you ended up with an FBI agent who cares so much about your life," it isn't going to work.

Trying to narrow the gap between ourselves and the other side is a mistake. An instinctive and understandable one, but a mistake all the same. The solution lies in our willingness to see how we truly look to the other side. That means asking ourselves, courageously, how we appear to our family members at the very moment we are trying to get them to change their behavior.

Who Am I, Really? Looking in the Mirror and Seeing a Different Face - illustration

In the case of the weight loss, I can say: "You probably think it's really insensitive of me to talk to you about your weight, since I've never struggled with being overweight and I have no idea how hard it is. I imagine you feel that I can never be pleased, that I belittle all your other accomplishments, and that I always find something negative to seize on." To my son I say: "I probably sound like a real nag, and anxious, with all this fuss about cigarettes. And maybe it even seems like I have no idea what social pressures you're dealing with, and I must sound completely out of touch when I can't understand on my own why smoking is cool." See the difference? I do this honestly and courageously, without sarcasm and without manipulation, and in doing so I raise the chances of getting cooperation.

Several things happen after a statement like this. First, I'm working less hard. Presenting the gaps between me and the other side as smaller than they are takes more effort than presenting them as they are. And when I'm working less hard, I'm less tense, and that affects the entire conversation. Another advantage is that I defuse much of the potential for the criticism the other person holds against me. He may still think I'm a nag and anxious, but somehow it sounds far less defiant when I'm the one who said it first.

My willingness to see myself from the other person's point of view can also change the way I behave within the relationship. After all, if I can see that my husband thinks I always find something negative to seize on, that realization can prompt me to explicitly acknowledge more of his accomplishments, or other positive aspects of our relationship. My readiness to present the gaps between me and the other side as large lends more credibility to my words and to my view of the world. And a realistic view of oneself, along with the capacity to bear self-criticism, brings hearts closer than passive-aggressive behavior, self-righteousness, or prettifying reality.

When the foundation of the relationship is good, the other side may well object to the harsh way we portrayed ourselves. The husband will say, "It's okay, I know you're just worried about me," and the son may surprise me with: "It's okay, Mom, I'm worried about it too, and I'm trying to find a way to keep this little problem from turning into a big one."

As I noted at the end of the previous column, what holds for the husband and the child holds here too for the neighbor I want to turn her music down, the woman at work whose problems I have no time to listen to, or the shop owner where I'm exchanging, for the third time, the shoes I bought. If I present myself as the nagging neighbor who always ruins every party, the unfriendly colleague who isn't interested in anyone, or the difficult customer who can never be satisfied, there's a good chance each of these conflicts will come to an end much faster.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page