When Dad Finds Love at the Office: How to Talk to Your Kids About Infidelity
Updated: Oct 22
It's hard to be happy for your ex when they've found new love — and even harder not to badmouth the third party in front of your kids. Here's how to deal with the pain and the betrayal without dragging your children into it, and even grow from it
Picture a father telling his kids: "Remember Shuli, the lawyer from my office? Well, the woman you think broke up our family — she and I are moving in together, and I'm planning to marry her and have children with her."
Now picture the kids relaying that news to their mother. And then picture the following response (which has probably occurred only a handful of times in the entire history of humanity): "That's fine, your father found new love, and I hope I will too… Actually, now that I think about it, I had a fling with someone three years ago, back when I was still with your dad. Maybe I'll give him a call and see if we can reconnect…"
In other words, when a couple splits up because one partner's relationship with someone else came to light, it's only natural that, at least for a while, both parents lose some of their capacity to hold back in front of their shared children, to feel genuinely happy for their ex, and to do the kind of honest soul-searching the situation calls for.
At the same time, it's important to try to avoid sharing with your child a version of events like, for instance: "That b***h Shuli broke up his family because she's twenty years younger than his father and decided to go after him for his money."
Not the Monster You Described
If we do that, we risk trapping our child in one of the following binds, both of which stem from the fact that they'll still need to build some kind of relationship with the "other woman." What happens, for instance, if over the course of getting to know Shuli, the child discovers she isn't a negative person at all, and is nothing like the monster you described? And just how easy are you making yourself to manipulate, in the process?
Depending on what she needs in the moment, your daughter can now easily come home and tell you, "Shuli said I'm fat, and it's probably because of what I eat at home." Bang — just like that, she's sprung the trap on you. It doesn't even matter whether Shuli actually said it or not; you're already in, allied with your daughter against the other side. And from a third angle, if the child has a well-developed superego, they may find themselves caught in a genuinely difficult moral dilemma.
Because while we, as adults, can actually understand how something like this happened with Shuli — we know people fall in love, we know people change, we know they sometimes fall in love out of a midlife crisis, and yet it's a genuine kind of love all the same — a child simply can't hold that much complexity.
A teenage girl can easily decide, with total conviction, that "as far as I'm concerned, infidelity is unforgivable" — and find herself forming an alliance with the betrayed parent, at the expense of her relationship with the parent who strayed (and there's no shortage of male "Shulis," of course), in a way that will end up hurting her in the long run.
Decades can go by before she's mature enough to realize that the picture painted for her at home, by the hurt parent, may have distorted reality — that it harnessed her innocence and robbed her of the chance to have a good relationship with the parent who broke the trust between her parents.

Things Happen
The key to avoiding this kind of harm to your children has to do with how you frame the affair itself in your own mind. You can see an affair as a one-sided breach of trust, a break caused by one partner in an otherwise intact relationship. But you can also see it as bad luck, or as a failure of the relationship as a whole. The first option means telling yourself, simply, that "things happen."
And indeed, things happen. People meet other people, and sometimes, with no bad intentions and no wish to hurt anyone, people fall in love. To some degree, everyone is exposed to the possibility that their partner will one day, under different circumstances, meet someone who feels like the true love of their life — and that meeting will leave them devastated.
It's not desirable, and we wish it hadn't happened, but the truth is that it's human, that it can happen, and it doesn't require us to conclude that our partner is bad, cruel, or a sadist. It only requires deep regret — and understanding that they're sorry too, that they would also have preferred this not to happen, but something did happen, and now the two of you have to deal with that "something."
The other option, of course, is to treat it as a shared failure. It's shared because it's also a failure of the betrayed partner — a failure to see. Say, for example, that a man lives with a woman and discovers she's been having an affair for three years.
In our society, that's likely seen as immoral behavior. But from a psychological standpoint, the real question is: how is it possible that he lived with his wife for three years and never picked up on it? Maybe she's simply a brilliant liar — but either way, it's also possible to see the breakdown of the marriage as a failure of their relationship as a system.
Yes, she's the one who did it — but the system failed. If a parallel relationship managed to survive for three years alongside their marriage, then the betrayed partner may not be doing himself any favors, in terms of his own growth, if he simply disowns his share of the responsibility for what happened.
Did he treat his partner in a way that left her no room to breathe? Or was he living with someone he had no real idea who she was? Because if you're living with someone capable of doing this for that long a stretch of time, that too is a kind of insight worth arriving at.
Or maybe it's connected to the fact that you didn't notice she was missing something she went looking for elsewhere. That, too, is worth taking responsibility for. And incidentally, in most cases we're not talking about people with narcissistic personality disorder or psychopathy — but if that does turn out to be the case, it's certainly worth examining our own share of responsibility for having lived with such a person without having any idea.
Taking that kind of responsibility will help you learn from the experience, for your own sake and for the rest of your life, and it will protect your children from becoming casualties of pain you never processed or worked through. But if you can't manage your own anger, and you act it out and leave your kids to digest it in its raw form, there's a real chance that this is simply another round of the same relational pathology — and, in fact, part of the reason you ended up here to begin with.
The Honest Side of Infidelity
For your children's sake, it's important to remember that the partner who cheated on you didn't cheat on them. What they need from their parent is something entirely different from what you need. And even if they lash out at that parent with a righteous fury you passed on to them, a parent who has done their own emotional work — one who knows how to take responsibility for their own feelings — will be able to handle their children even in the case of infidelity toward the other parent.
If she's an emotionally mature, responsible adult, the partner who was unfaithful to you can tell the children that she did something she isn't proud of, or that at first she didn't think her new relationship could ever replace the family they had.
She can explain that the family mattered enough to her that she tried to manage this complicated situation, but in the end she couldn't, and that she's genuinely sorry it came out and caused their father pain. If her affair is with someone she believes could give her a much better life, she can even point out to the children that there was sacrifice involved here too.
The point is, if you look at yourself honestly, you may discover there's another side to the story of the affair. From the perspective of the partner who left the relationship, it's possible the new partner simply suits them far better. Or even that being single would suit them best of all — and yet, day after day, they came home, got into bed, and woke up in the morning next to a partner who, unfortunately, was you.
All of that, out of commitment to the family. So maybe they don't deserve a medal for it — but it's also far from certain that everyone they and your children will meet over the course of their lives will agree with you that they belong in the town square, tied to a post of shame.
A worldview that divides the world into the good and the bad has serious limits, and if your relationship fell apart because of infidelity, it's worth it — both for your own personal growth and for your children's sake — to move past that framework and toward a more complex understanding of the situation.
If all you're really interested in is forming a coalition with the kids, or with your ex's parents (that happens too), or coming out looking like the good guy in the story, chances are you're deceiving yourself. The alternative — for your own sake and your children's — is to take responsibility for your part in the unfortunate thing that happened.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




