top of page

"Suddenly I Understood What to Call What I've Been Going Through With My Sister Since We Were Little"

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 27, 2022
7 min read

"My sister and I agreed to make an elaborate film for our mom's birthday — I'd handle the creative work, she'd cover the costs. The film was a hit, and my sister happily took credit for it too, but she still owes me thousands of shekels, and makes me feel bad whenever I bring it up. Help, I'm no longer sure what's normal."

Hi Amalia,

I recently came across the term "gaslighting," and it opened my eyes to what I've been going through with my sister since we were little. Here's a story to illustrate: a few months ago, my sister and I decided to make an elaborate video for our mom's birthday. We agreed that I would create it — production, filming, and professional editing — and she would fund the work and the equipment it required.

The work on the film was demanding and long, and the costs came to 5,000 shekels. At the start, my sister "tossed" me $300, since she'd just gotten back from New York and wanted to get rid of it (and I had to bother converting it myself). Since then, she hasn't shown any interest in the matter.

Our mom's birthday came and went, the film was a big hit, and my sister of course thoroughly enjoyed taking credit and compliments for it. The next day, I reminded her she still owed about 4,000 shekels. She ignored the message. Two weeks later I reminded her again, and she said she was taking care of it. A week after that I wrote that I wasn't seeing any deposit in my bank account, and she replied: "Too bad you didn't tell me in advance that you'd need proof of the transfer."

It's so confusing! On one hand, I'm sure she never transferred the money; on the other, she's got me going back through every recent transaction in my bank account, in case I'm the idiot who "missed" her deposit! Help — am I dealing with a narcissistic sister?

Neta

"Suddenly I Understood What to Call What I've Been Going Through With My Sister Since We Were Little" - illustration

Dear Neta,

I obviously can't say with certainty whether your sister has narcissistic personality disorder, but the pattern of behavior that comes through in your story is certainly consistent with one. Let me point out a few things that stand out to me:

First, the fact that the crisis between you erupted around money. Money is a fairly reliable litmus test when it comes to emotional disorders, because it's a clear marker of separateness. In other words, the money is either with you or with your sister — it can't be with both of you at once. In that sense, dealing with money can be a major trigger for people who struggle with separateness. Specifically, people with narcissistic personality disorder — depending on how severe it is — sometimes struggle to tolerate the very existence of another person. When the other person expresses a need of their own (in your case, the need to actually receive the money from her), that need becomes a trigger for the narcissist, and is often experienced by them as outright aggression.

People with narcissistic traits struggle to accept that another person exists as a separate being

I don't know what childhood circumstances caused your sister to struggle so much with tolerating other-ness (often, the roots lie in a significant caregiver's own inability to accept the child's separateness, responding to it harshly), but it seems the very fact that the two of you are separate beings is something that threatens her. When you express your need to be compensated for your work, emotionally speaking, it doesn't much matter that this was something you agreed on together in advance, with her full participation in that agreement. In practice, you're putting a demand in front of her to recognize that you exist.

Second, there's the matter of paying you in dollars. We sometimes assume that people with narcissistic personality disorder believe they're entitled to special privileges, and that's why they behave however they please toward the people around them. In practice, they behave that way because they struggle to recognize that other people exist as separate from them. In other words, in their perception, their own experience and the other person's experience are one and the same. In your sister's case, with the dollars — it was convenient for her to pay you in dollars, and because she struggles to imagine that you have a different center of experience and different considerations than her own, she simply assumed this would be a great solution for you too.

A third point is the very division of labor between you: a situation where you do all the work and she just pays fits better with a business dynamic between, say, a director and an investor. If you'd told me your life's dream was to direct a film about an 80-year-old woman and your sister was willing to fund that dream, I'd read the story differently. But the woman in the film is both of your mother! Your sister wanted to share credit for the work, which tells me it really did matter to her to make a meaningful gesture for this birthday — but the way you divided the labor points to a real problem with collaboration.

Now, to the matter of the money not being transferred, and the way you've communicated about it. You may already be starting to realize, at this point, that your sister isn't necessarily tormenting you on purpose, but is operating according to her own emotional logic. That logic says: if it's not urgent for her to transfer you the money, then it shouldn't be urgent for you to receive it either.

As I said, your insistence that you're a separate person from her, someone for whom actually receiving the money genuinely matters, is, from her side, a very unpleasant experience. It can stir up a whole range of feelings in her — from hurt ("Is this what our relationship is worth to her? Does everything come down to money?") to anger ("Why is she bothering me again about this pathetic bit of money?"). Either way, she keeps ignoring your needs.

If you're still not fully sure what you're experiencing from your sister, I have a trick I use often to help people recognize that they're victims of gaslighting. The trick is to imagine how a psychologically healthy person, someone without narcissistic personality disorder, would have responded to your message about the delayed payment — and then compare that imagined response to the one you actually got.

A person without narcissistic traits would have tried to understand you, and even apologized

In this case, if your sister were someone without this kind of personality disorder, then already by your second message, she would have done one of the following: called you to apologize (rather than settling for a text), because she'd feel bad about having made things hard for you; she'd try to figure out for herself what mistake she'd made, and share that with you; and of course, she'd transfer the rest of the money immediately. If she had some financial difficulty making it hard for her to pay you, she would have talked to you about it openly and asked for more time. In short, she would have behaved like someone who owes a debt — not like someone acting as if you're the one who owes her something.

Instead, your sister sent you a message blaming you: "Too bad you didn't tell me in advance that you'd need proof of the transfer." That's a message with no remorse in it, no acknowledgment of the facts, of your needs, or of her own slip-up. It contains suppressed anger, and it also contains an actual falsehood. I say "actual" because, incomprehensibly, your sister seems to genuinely believe she already transferred you the money — perhaps because she'd already bothered to think about the matter once before, and concluded from that alone that, as far as you were concerned too, she'd already paid.

And by the way, you don't need to keep checking your bank account over and over: it's possible she really did transfer the money and you missed it (that happens to all of us), but that's not really the point. If your sister didn't have this kind of personality structure, how would she have told you she'd already transferred the money? She probably would have said something like: "Listen, sweetie, I'm pretty sure I sent the money, I'm a bit swamped and not sure I'll get to check again, so I'll double check tomorrow or the day after. If it didn't go through — I am so sorry, and I'll fix it right away."

Now go back to the response you actually got from her. Is your sister a narcissist? The answer is, unfortunately, probably yes.

Recommendations

Icon: Bill Burr

Bill Burr's latest stand-up special, "Live at Red Rocks," is on Netflix. I know this is a controversial recommendation: some people see Burr as an aggressive, misogynistic white guy. I disagree. To my mind, his humor is super sophisticated, and belongs to the same brand of comedy that gave us Jack Donaghy on "30 Rock." So maybe I'm coming across as the least sensitive person alive here — but I haven't laughed that hard in a decade.

Burr is like the Houdini of stand-up. He gets himself into situations that seem impossible to escape, and then pulls off genuinely brilliant comedic moves that leave you with your jaw dropped and tears of laughter in your eyes. His set feels more like reading a truly hilarious book than the average stand-up experience.

Website: Disarming the Narcissist

Psychotherapist Wendy Behary has dedicated her career to treating people with narcissistic disorders, mainly through a schema-therapy approach, and to treating high-conflict couples. Some of the training videos on her website have helped my own clinical work in extraordinary ways, and her site is full of high-quality resources, including links to online support groups for people married to narcissistic partners.

Health: Pickle Juice

I've written here before about the major contribution fermented foods make to our microbiome, and through it, to our immune system. On another occasion, I wrote about how drinking salted water helps manage hunger when we're trying to cut calories, and also helps with recovery after exercise.

And, as you know, I'm a huge fan of supplements. So this recommendation is a particular favorite of mine, since it combines all three of the previous tips into one: swallow some of your vitamins with pickle juice. You get the salt, you get the probiotics, and taking your vitamins becomes a little less boring.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page