top of page

Parental Gaslighting: "What, Us?"

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Nov 7, 2024
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Many parents hide from their children — and from themselves — that they're about to separate, brushing off the hard questions with denial. Why broadcasting "business as usual" when nothing is usual backfires, and what hiding the truth really costs

One line my father used to repeat throughout my childhood was, "I hit the jackpot with your mother." Winning the lottery, of course, was his metaphor for something good happening against all odds. I remember that line mainly because I knew that wasn't how he actually felt.

My parents didn't like each other. They started living in separate houses when I was 18, and when I was 26 they called to tell me they were getting divorced. My reaction was, "Finally." But underneath that, I felt something else too: betrayed. Betrayed by the facade of the wonderful family I'd been asked to uphold and represent for so many years of my childhood, even when it was completely clear to me that the relationship between them was terrible.

I'm not the only one who has found themselves in that position. Plenty of children ask their parents whether they're about to split up, and get the answer, "What? No, not us" — even though the true answer is, "Unfortunately, there's a good chance it will happen."

Sometimes parents answer that way out of their own need to distance themselves from something that frightens them too; sometimes they treat the child's question as proof to themselves that the kids don't want them to divorce. But those moments, when your child asks what's going on between you, are also a chance to call yourself to order. The question doesn't have to be spelled out — even if you're in the middle of an escalating marital crisis and the school counselor calls to say your child has been stealing things from other kids' backpacks, that's an opportunity to take yourself in hand.

Beware: A Fragile Façade

When we deny the crisis our children can feel, a gap opens up between what they sense intuitively and what they're told about the situation. Of course, some couples manage, at exactly that moment, to do a U-turn — to work out whether the relationship is worth fighting for, and actually start working on it. But when that's not the case, it's a chance to start closing the gap between what's really happening behind closed doors and the picture of your relationship you're painting for your children.

It's true that in families where the parents shout at each other and fight, the children suffer. But in families where everything looks fine right up until the moment it all falls apart, the children often suffer more — especially once the separation actually happens.

When parents keep up polite, easy small talk in front of everyone (a habit that crosses every background), go together to Friday dinners with the extended family, and maintain the family façade even though the relationship underneath has already rotted through, the child has to spend far more emotional energy coming to terms with the realization that it's all fake — both in the marriage's final stretch and during the divorce itself.

During the marriage, when the parents are openly not getting along, it isn't pleasant for anyone — but it at least allows the child to talk about it with siblings, with one of the parents, or with someone else close to the family.

Whoever the child talks to understands what's going on, and the child feels that their thoughts and worries are legitimate. But when the cracks run deep and are simply papered over, the child struggles to put a finger on the problem, and can feel — within themselves, in front of others, and certainly in front of their parents — that they're not allowed to complain, because everything is supposedly fine.

If the family is calm and quiet on the surface, but the parents have stopped sleeping together and don't talk about it, the child knows something is going on. They watch movies and shows, they see other people's families, and they know that in most families, the parents sharing a bed is basic to what "home," "family," and "couple" even mean.

And on top of that, a silence hangs over the subject — even though these same parents know perfectly well how to talk to their child about plenty of other things when they want to. In practice, you could even say that when we try to protect our children from the hard truth of our relationship, we may actually be gaslighting them.

Parental Gaslighting: "What, Us?" - illustration

A Crisis of Judgment

The effects of that kind of concealment outlast the divorce itself. When the concealment has gone on for a long time, children can develop a kind of hypervigilance as a result, because they've learned to be skeptical. Life has taught them that even when everything looks fine, and the people closest to them seem content, none of it can be trusted.

In a sense, they experience part of what someone goes through when they discover, one day, that their partner has been unfaithful. Affairs often happen because partners respond differently to a gap that already exists between them. One side was aware that the relationship wasn't giving them much satisfaction, while the other was living in denial and repression.

When the betrayed partner finds out, they can fall into a major crisis with themselves, and ask important questions: How could I not have seen this happening? How could I have thought I knew what the other person was thinking, and where they stood emotionally?

In other words, a crisis like that affects the betrayed person's trust in their partner, but also their trust in themselves. The question now isn't only whether I can trust my partner again, but what this says about my own judgment and my ability to see clearly. A similar process can happen to children who suddenly discover their parents were never in the place, as a couple, that they claimed to be.

Parents, Tell the Real Story

Does that mean couples going through a quiet, slow death of a marriage should start throwing plates? Not necessarily — but if you're heading toward separation, there's real value in gradually exposing your children to the new reality.

If, say, you've reached a point where you simply can't stand your husband's family and have no respect for them anymore, maybe it's time to stop going to those Friday dinners. After all, your children know exactly how you act when you go see a friend you actually enjoy being with, and they know what face you make when your husband brings up his mother or his brother. So what is your child supposed to think when you go there and pretend everything is fine? Better not to go — and let the emotional pieces that make up your children's lives start connecting into a coherent picture.

The children will begin to have what they feel — and don't dare ask about — validated. A story will start to form: Mom and Dad really don't get along. The truth is she can't stand him or his family, and he looks down on her hobbies (or whatever it happens to be), and on top of it they no longer sleep together. In other words, it doesn't have to be a dramatic story, but it's a story built out of real pieces — one that connects, for the children, things they're already seeing and already know.

That doesn't mean that when you finally sit them down for the big conversation, you need to dump the whole case file on them and say, "You've probably noticed that Dad hasn't come to our activities these last few years, and we don't go to parent-teacher conferences together — well, all of that was actually a sign of something much more serious." In real time, it's enough to say, "Mom isn't joining us for dinner tonight because this situation makes her uncomfortable." By the time the separation happens, these things will have already connected, on their own, into your child's understanding that something was wrong.

The added benefit, as noted, is that your child will come out of this crisis feeling less deceived than children whose parents told them they'd hit the jackpot with each other. That trust matters — both because it shapes the child's own future relationships, and because it shapes how they relate to their parents.

Parents who maintain a peaceful appearance throughout their marriage and then dismantle the relationship may, in effect, be making a trade: buying themselves and their children a small illusion of calm, while actually selling off their child's trust in them. The child may well arrive at the conclusion that their parents can no longer be relied on as honest narrators of reality.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page