New Kinds of Families Require New Kinds of Thinking: A Book Week Interview
Updated: Oct 22
A book published by the founders of Israel's "Center for Alternative Parenting" aims to support men and women who want to become parents without a romantic partnership or shared household. In conversation, they explain what parents on this path need to work through, and what the model's advantages are
Hebrew Book Week is a good excuse to celebrate the publication of a new book that fills a real gap, and stands out, in Israel's conversation about the family: "Shared Parenting: Breaking Up With the Cinderella Story," by Racheli Bar-Or and Gidi Shavit. Bar-Or and Shavit are social workers and psychotherapists (Shavit is also a family and couples therapist) who founded the Center for Alternative Parenting together in 1994, to support men and women who want to become parents without being a couple and without sharing a household. The center is still active today, and the two note with pride that "hundreds of children have been born through our services."
The foundation on which the Center for Alternative Parenting's family structure rests is the separation and distinction between parenting and coupledom. The family model is what they call a "dual-nucleus" family. The two wrote the book after years of closely accompanying couples through the center. The book aims to offer support to people building a family for themselves within an alternative framework like the one the center offers. According to Bar-Or and Shavit, the biggest difficulty parents on this path face is coming to terms with the reality of it.

What's the most important piece of advice you'd give someone interested in entering a process like this?
Bar-Or: "Come into the process with an open mind and good intentions. Choose out of hope, not only out of fear. The process is complex, so it's best to accompany it with psychological therapy and to build the parental relationship on a safety net — to write a meticulous, detailed contract that serves as a safety net for the family structure and addresses the needs of the child, the father and the mother." Shavit adds that it's important to remember the contract isn't only a legal document, but first and foremost a psychological contract about a relationship — and that the process of drafting it matters enormously.
I asked the two of them what the advantages are of building a family this way compared with the traditional path. Bar-Or says they often hear envy from fathers and mothers in traditional parenting arrangements toward parents raising children this way, and explains that the envy may stem from the fact that the structure gives each parent free time and space for themselves and their own needs, as set out in the agreement. Another major advantage the two point to is the flexibility of the parenting structure, which lets each parent come to time with the child with longing and freshness. As a result, they say, the child gets quality time with each parent individually, and sometimes, when it suits them, with both together.
Bar-Or and Shavit see several advantages to building a family this way over single parenthood — in the spirit of "two are better than one." Both parents share the practical, financial and emotional load, backing each other up. In addition, Shavit explains, "the space of real, emotional connections available to the child is larger — the child has two parents, two significant others."
Bar-Or adds that in a dual-nucleus family like this, the child also won't be preoccupied with questions about their genetic origins. Their father and mother raise them within a stable form of parenting that doesn't depend on a romantic relationship and can't come apart — not even through divorce. In her view, when there's no romance at the base of the relationship, it's actually easier to protect the foundation of the family: cooperation, mutual respect and affection.
Asked whether anything in the book is relevant to couples building a family the "regular" way too, Bar-Or and Shavit say the book carries a basic message that's important and relevant to any couple planning to have children together: practical alignment of expectations ahead of the child's arrival.
"It's important to discuss and decide how the burden of parenting will be divided, both together and separately," they say. "Early coordination on time, housing, career, work, hobbies and so on. These issues come up for nearly every couple, and they become far sharper once children are born — sharp enough to spark real conflict. The book suggests clarifying parents' expectations and reaching agreements before the child arrives, even before pregnancy." Another element in the book, relevant in their view to new parents of any kind, is a mutual commitment to a mechanism for resolving disagreements — something that can help any parents through the long journey of raising children.
A shared-parenting agreement sometimes resembles a divorce agreement, so I asked them to sharpen the key difference between an agreement that builds a family this way and a divorce agreement. "Both agreements are built from the same practical elements of life we all navigate around — time, money, distance between homes, and so on," Shavit says, "but the central difference is that the shared-parenting agreement is drawn up out of affection, joy and an intention to build forward, while the divorce agreement is drawn up out of rupture and pain, a breakdown of trust and the dismantling of a family structure. This agreement is signed before the pregnancy, and it builds a path of partnership and separateness at the same time."
The difference isn't only in the agreement, but also in the experience of a child who grows up in a family like this, compared with a child who grows up with divorced parents. "A child of divorced parents experiences a major rupture in their world — before, during and after the divorce," Bar-Or explains. "A child in a dual-nucleus family, by contrast, is born and grows up into a given reality, agreed upon and stable, which they've known their whole life." Still, they note, the longing for the parents to unite exists, and is felt, among children of dual-nucleus families too.
Because of the nature of my own work, I sometimes meet people who built a family through shared parenting and aren't happy with the choice they made. But according to Bar-Or and Shavit, these aren't most people. They say most parents are very satisfied both with their choice of family structure and with the specific partner they chose. "Most of them understand, even before the pregnancy, that they carry a parental responsibility to maintain a respectful, pleasant, communicative relationship — and that in the absence of the romantic component, the basis of the relationship is accepting the other person and cooperating with them," Shavit says.
Shavit also points out that, as in any human relationship, even in these new kinds of families there are, depending on personality, people who struggle to carry through the decision to co-parent, or the choice of partner. "Typically, these are couples who skipped signing an expectations-alignment contract before the pregnancy, and who ignored the difficulties between them," he says. According to him, most of this small minority of couples turn to counseling and support aimed at preserving the existing foundation, out of a deep recognition of its importance. Usually, over time, and as the child grows, mutual acceptance builds.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




