top of page

"I Did Everything for My Kids - So Why Are They Angry at Me?"

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Dec 8, 2022
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Reader Nili can't understand why, after years of working hard to support, provide for, and love her children unconditionally, her grown kids still turn up their noses and seem unhappy with her. Reader Yair thought he'd met "the one" - until dessert arrived at the restaurant. Amalia answers readers' questions

Dear Amalia,

My kids (27, 21, 17) are furious with me, and I don't know why. I've worked incredibly hard all these years to give them everything they need. Their father and I divorced a long time ago, and I'm more financially successful than he is, so most of the burden of raising them has fallen on me. In general, I'm an ambitious, energetic person with a rich inner life, and that's let me be there for them without giving up anything for myself. I never got into a new relationship – I stay plenty interested between my books, my work, and my sports. And it also meant I could be at every graduation, every game, and I even chaperoned school trips.

And yet I feel like they're irritable with me, unhappy with me, rolling their eyes at each other and snapping at me, but when I try to figure out from them what the problem actually is, I don't really get anywhere. Their lives are good, overall, if you ask me. They haven't completely found themselves yet, but that makes sense at their age. They're sociable, intelligent, funny, attractive and talented. A little spoiled for my taste, scattering their energy across interests I don't quite see leading anywhere, but maybe that's a generational thing.

As people, they're not easy at all. They swing between shutting themselves off, with partners whose true colors I still haven't fully figured out, without telling me anything – or talking about themselves nonstop without ever once, even out of politeness, asking how I'm doing. I'd love to hear what you think is going on here.

Nili (not her real name)

Dear Nili,

Let me skip past the validation and just say it's clear how hard you're working to give your kids the best, and it also seems like you're someone used to your efforts paying off. So when you're working this hard at parenting and your kids are still unhappy, something isn't adding up for you. Obviously I'm seeing a very partial picture, and anything I say is inherently superficial, so take my answer with a grain of salt – but it seems to me that what you might be struggling with, like so many parents, is actually being curious about your children.

Every meaningful relationship, I think, has three basic dimensions. The first is belonging and loyalty; the second is affection and attraction; and the third is support for identity. In different categories of relationship, different dimensions take priority. Within a family, feelings of belonging and loyalty are usually the most important. This typically shows up as a person's sense that their family has their back, and will be there for them in their lowest, hardest moments.

In a romantic relationship, the most important layer is affection and attraction. The sheer number of affairs people have is itself evidence that belonging and loyalty – that is, a sense of family – aren't essential to sustaining a romantic bond. Friendship, meanwhile, I think, rests mainly on support for identity: the feeling that my friend understands me, and I understand her.

I'd guess there's also an evolutionary, survival-based logic behind these different relationship profiles: the survival function of the family is to protect its weaker members – children and the elderly – so loyalty and belonging have to be front and center. The biological function of a couple is to bring children into the world, so attraction is the dominant element there. And the parallel function of friendship is to create cooperation, thereby boosting the survival chances of the individual and the group – so support for identity is the most critical aspect of that kind of bond. That doesn't mean support for identity and mutual understanding shouldn't also exist within a family bond.

From your description, it's clear you're absolutely meeting the first and most central condition of a relationship: you provide shelter and cover for your children, and even when they treat you disrespectfully or hurt you, your commitment to them doesn't waver – which is exactly why you're writing to me now.

I think the second condition is met too. Of course, affection and attraction within a family relationship operate on a different frequency than the erotic frequency between romantic partners, but there's still real meaning in family members simply delighting in each other, and from the way you describe your kids, it's clear they delight you.

It looks like there's a weakness on the third axis – the identity-support axis. If loyalty and belonging show up in your ability to be there for your children when they're down, the identity-support axis shows up in your ability to be there for them when they're up. The trick here is to get curious about their inner world and their experiences, especially in exactly the places that don't interest you, or that they don't necessarily talk to you about.

You're not alone in this. Plenty of parents struggle to take a real interest in their kids, and phones have made this a lot harder. How is a child mumbling on for an hour about some vague fight at school supposed to interest me as much as a recommendation for a gadget I'm considering buying? What's supposed to grab my attention while I'm watching my kid at soccer practice, and how is that supposed to be more meaningful than answering that work email that's been waiting since noon? For the record, I'm writing all this from a place of real identification – there's no shortage of days when I ask myself, "What am I doing here at a Scouts necktie ceremony? Just give me strong Wi-Fi and let me get on with changing the world."

And yet, when we don't take an interest in our children's inner world, and don't challenge ourselves to find a way to support even the parts of their identity that we don't understand, and that might even feel threatening to us, that comes at a price.

Good luck,

Amalia

"I Did Everything for My Kids - So Why Are They Angry at Me?" - illustration

Hi Amalia,

I'm a 40-year-old single man with no kids, and I think I've met "the one." She's smart, beautiful, works in an interesting field, and is at the same stage of life as me. The problem is (why is there always a problem?) that she says she suffers terribly from the sounds I make while chewing. It didn't come up on our first two dates, because we sat in noisy places and only ordered small plates, but now we're already sleeping over at each other's places, and the moment real food enters the picture, she visibly shudders. Every meal turns into a saga, and I've completely given up on dessert. I don't know whether to be offended or not, whether to get out of this relationship now before it's too late, or whether she's just crazy. What do you think? Have you ever heard of anything like this?

Thanks,

Yair (not his real name)

Dear Yair,

Your girlfriend may be suffering from an auditory sensitivity condition called "misophonia," a word built from "hate" (miso, as in "misogyny," which means hatred of women) plus "sound" (phonia, as in "phonetic"). It's essentially a combination of a neurological disorder and a psychiatric one, in the sense that certain sounds make the person who has it feel genuinely attacked, triggering intense, immediate negative reactions toward the source of the noise.

The tricky part is that most people with misophonia don't react this way to a garbage truck idling under their window at 4:30 in the morning – instead, they have a severe emotional reaction to common, everyday sounds, usually ones made by other people, that most people don't even register at all. In your case it's your chewing, but it could just as easily be a child's yawn or the way someone close to them breathes.

In other words, your girlfriend isn't crazy. I don't know if that helps you. Research has recently started coming out on the possibility of treating misophonia through cognitive behavioral therapy. If she really is "the one," and you're "the one" for her too, it might be worth the two of you looking into that treatment path.

Good luck,

Amalia

Recommendations

Supplements: Ease Up on Vitamin C

This week it felt like the only sign of winter was sufganiyot and runny noses. After two and a half years of Covid, during which we didn't leave the house but at least didn't catch the flu, it now seems like everyone's sniffling or coughing. Some of us hate being sick so much, and dread catching something so intensely, that we can talk ourselves into believing huge doses of vitamin C are the best way to shorten a cold, or even prevent one entirely. This is a good moment to really think through whether that's actually the right solution for you.

Many forms of vitamin C, when taken in amounts well above the recommended dose on the label, can cause serious digestive irritation, which can lead to diarrhea, heartburn and vomiting. "More" isn't always better – vitamin C is a perfect example of that.

Podcast: Peter Attia Talks With Psychologist and Author Lori Gottlieb

Lori Gottlieb wrote the book "Maybe You Should Talk to Someone," writes a regular column for The Atlantic, and hosts a popular podcast called Dear Therapists. In this episode she's a guest on Peter Attia's show, talking with him about the patients from her book, about her own path both as a patient and as a therapist, and about the world of therapy in general. She's modest, articulate, and even though her therapeutic approach differs from the emotionally focused therapy I practice, there's genuinely a lot to learn from her.

With the Kids: The Lensa App

In the universe of things you absolutely don't need, this is one of the hottest trends around. Using AI (at least supposedly), this app takes photos you like of yourself and generates a huge number of wildly flattering, imaginative avatars based on them. You don't need to download it onto every family member's phone – just download it on one device and use it to generate different avatars for everyone. Our family loved it so much we even tried making one for the dog.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page