Even Good Parents Can Cause Their Children Trauma
Updated: Oct 22
It's easy to see it as trauma when a child has been abused by a parent. But children can also suffer from quiet traumas, which can arise even from parents who are too busy surviving
Ronen (a pseudonym; all these columns are written at the clients' request) shifts uncomfortably when I talk about his childhood in terms of trauma. Together we're trying to understand whether his childhood experiences are connected to the fact that when he travels abroad he barely contacts his wife, who stays in Israel with their three children. Covid reduced Ronen's travel for a while, and that friction eased, but recently Ronen has gone back to flying for work, and although he doesn't especially enjoy these trips, mostly to a gray city in Germany, and despite the free evenings, he hardly ever calls home.
"What would happen at your house when you came home from school?" I ask.
Ronen gives me a puzzled look, as if to say, "What could possibly happen?"
"Who would be waiting for you?" I press. "What questions would they ask you? What did lunch look like? Who would sit with you to do homework?"
Ronen's look is still fairly blank. After a moment he stirs and says that most mornings he would wake up to a living room empty of adults. His mother worked in a government office and left the house before the rest of the household woke up in order to reach Jerusalem on time. His father often worked night shifts at a hospital and would try to catch up on sleep in the morning. Ronen and his older sister would wake up on their own to an alarm clock, each of them would make themselves something small to eat, and then they'd leave for their schools. Ronen on his bike, and his sister by bus to a school farther away.
Coming home wasn't much cheerier. Ronen would arrive at an empty house and heat up his own lunch. His sister studied until later in the day, and usually went on alone from school to her ballet lessons. His parents insisted that he needed to rest between two and four in the afternoon, so he wasn't allowed to go out and play with friends right away, and he was supposed to use the hot hours to do his homework.
There was no note waiting for him from his parents, and no special phone he could use to call them and exchange a few words. On the fridge was a note with emergency numbers only, and the only time Ronen used that note was when the neighbor upstairs died and an ambulance came to take her away. But even then, no one answered at his mother's office. He doesn't remember where his father was.
In the afternoons Ronen would play with friends. He was shy but well liked, and a decent athlete, and he usually had no trouble fitting into ball games. He generally enjoyed the independence and privacy that the family's lifestyle allowed him, but his childhood years also held quite a few crises, including bullying by other kids and run-ins with teachers at school. In those cases Ronen didn't know how to cope, and his shyness locked him inside walls of silence and embarrassment.
No one in the family knew about it. He'd get home around seven in the evening. And then he would usually see his mother for half an hour. She'd come back from Jerusalem around six, go lie down for half an hour, and then leave to look after her elderly mother, who lived in another neighborhood in the same city. She would usually return only after Ronen was already asleep. By seven, Ronen's father was already home, back from various errands, and by eight his sister would usually join them. The three of them would eat a very basic dinner together, which his father would set out before leaving for his night shift. When I asked, Ronen couldn't recall the conversations that he, his sister and his father had around the table.
"Who would you tell if you had difficulties or achievements at school?" I asked.
Ronen was taken aback.
"And if you needed help with something?" I pressed.
He shrugged.
"So," I try to understand, "on most days of your childhood, you didn't expect any response from your family members about your day, right?"
Ronen confirmed that I'd understood correctly. As a child he understood that his parents were working very hard to create for him and his sister a future with more options than they'd had, and that he was expected not to burden them or weigh on them. Looking back as an adult, you can see that his parents' struggle for survival flooded them so completely, physically, mentally and emotionally, that they had no energy left to enjoy their child, to take an interest in his inner world, or to care for needs beyond his physical ones. It's not so surprising, then, that when he's on a business trip in Germany his mind has trouble imagining that his wife and children in Israel would be glad to hear from him, would want to know how his meetings went, and might even want to share their own experiences with him.
Parents often have to be far from their children, but of course that doesn't mean they're far from them mentally. There are many ways to show interest in what isn't strictly necessary, to live together at home in a way that isn't instrumental, to ask open questions, to nurture the child's inner world and not only tend to material needs. Likewise, parents can be physically close to their children and still take no interest in their world and not be truly close to them. And along the way, it's worth asking, inside the "rat race," whether all our absence from home, at every stage of the child's development, is really unavoidable.

But Why Trauma?
"Okay," says Ronen, who manages to summon a little self-compassion for the child he was, "but why do you call it 'trauma'? I wasn't hit, I wasn't insulted, no one yelled at me. They just did the best they could."
"Of course," I agree. And still I insist that these events, which repeated day after day and year after year in Ronen's childhood, were traumatic. To understand this you need to understand that traumas fall into at least two types: traumas that add unwanted events to a child's developmental process, and traumas that subtract wanted events from it.
When a parent routinely hits, insults or yells at a child, he adds harsh experiences to the child's brain archive. In such cases it's easy for us to understand why it's trauma. But Ronen's case demonstrates well, in my view, why it's right to speak in terms of trauma even when a parent doesn't perform roles the child needs for healthy development. The world-renowned addiction expert I mentioned here last month, Gabor Maté, calls this type of trauma "trauma by omission." Trauma, he stresses, can arise both when something bad happens and when something good doesn't happen.
Although corporal punishment and violence leave severe scars on children, it's important to understand that traumas by omission create a specific and especially difficult kind of problem for children, precisely because they're hard to point to. A child who is harmed directly can often understand that something bad is happening. And even if he grows accustomed to harm in childhood, then at an older age, if he's lucky enough to find himself in healthy relationships, he'll usually be able to identify the problem that existed in his childhood.
But children who experience traumas in which important parental functions were dropped and neglected may be left with a very vague sense of the source of their emotional difficulty, even when they reach adulthood, as with Ronen. This becomes especially complicated when we realize that many parents create such traumas in their children without being violent or personality-disordered types whose dysfunction is easy to point to. Many parents, like Ronen's, truly do the best they can to survive, while often contending with historical traumas of their own. And there, between the chairs, in the place where their children fall, the quiet traumas grow.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




